Research on apparent resistivity and its influence of obliquely incident plane electromagnetic waves
Xiao Xiao,Fu Hong-Liu,Tang Jing-Tian,Liu Feng-Yi,Ren Zheng-Yong,Yuan Yuan,Zhang Lin-Cheng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.6038/cjg20151227
2015-01-01
Abstract:Both the conventional magnetotelluric method (MT) and audio-frequency magnetotelluric method ( AMT) without considering the influence of displacement currents are based on the hypothesis that planar electromagnetic waves are normally incident on the surface of the earth. In reality, such a case is not true and in some cases, the displacement currents cannot be neglected. This paper analyzes the relative difference of apparent resistivity of TE and TM modes in the condition of considering the displacement currents and planar electromagnetic waves are obliquely incident on the surface of the earth. The method that this paper adopted is numerical modeling. Based on Maxwell's equations, this paper deduces the impedance formula of planar electromagnetic waves that are obliquely incident on the layered earth under the total current condition in new ways and finishes the corresponding computation programs. The program correctness is verified with comparison to analytic solutions as well as published results. Based on this, the paper calculates and analyzes the apparent resistivity of TE and TM modes varying with displacement currents, incidence angle, magnetic permeability and dielectric peimittivity under the quasi-static limit and the total current condition. According to the various cases of the quasi-static limit and the total current condition, the following information of the relative difference of apparent resistivity of TE and TM modes could be obtained easily. 1) The change of the incidence angle has little impact on TE and TM modes' apparent resistivity under the quasi-static limit. In addition, the apparent resistivity has almost no difference between the two modes. 2) When the incidence angle equals zero, TE and TM modes' apparent resistivity equals each other, which is independent of earth resistivity, frequency, magnetic permeability and dielectric permittivity. As for earth resistivity is above 1000 am, when the incidence angle is below 30 degrees and frequency is less than 1000 kHz, the difference of the apparent resistivity of normally incident and obliquely incident could be ignored. When the incidence angle is greater than 30 degrees and frequency is above 1000 kHz, the difference between the apparent resistivity of normally incident and obliquely incident could not be neglected. At the same time, TE-mode's resistivity increases with the increase of incidence angle, while for TM mode, the opposite holds. Therefore, the difference of the two modes' resistivity increases with increasing incidence angle. Which acts fairly significant especially when frequency is above 1000kHz and incidence angle equals 60 degrees. 3) When the plane electromagnetic wave normally incidents, whether it is under the quasi-static condition, or under the total currents condition, if half-space permeability is not equal to free-space permeability, the calculated apparent resistivity will be mu(r), (mu(r) the relative permittivity) times of the true half-space resistivity. Under the total currents condition, if the plane electromagnetic wave obliquely incidents on the earth surface, TE-mode' s resistivity will be a little smaller than mu(r) times of the true half-space resistivity, while for TM mode, the opposite holds. This is not obvious when frequency is less than 100 kHz, while when frequency is greater than 100 kHz, it acts significantly. 4) As for earth resistivity is greater or equal to 2000 Omega m, the influence of dielectric permittivity on the differences of the two modes' resistivity could be ignored when frequency is less than 100 kHz. While when frequency is greater than 100 kHz, TE or TM-mode's resistivity decreases with the increase of dielectric permittivity. Under the condition of planar electromagnetic wave obliquely incidents, when there is a shallow overburden and frequency equals 1000 kHz, the relative error of the two modes' resistivity maintains 22. 5% varying with dielectric permittivity. In the exploration of the controlled-source audio-frequency magnetotelluric method (CSAMT), if the measured area is not far enough away from the source, it does not meet the planar wave hypothesis, hence the incidence angle should be taken into consideration. In AMT exploration, when the measurement point is located in a high-resistivity geological environment, the apparent resistivity curve of the high frequency section often drops compared to the simulation results under the quasi-static condition, probably because the displacement current cannot be ignored. In the actual exploration, the permeability of the shallow surface has a great influence on the high frequency apparent resistivity, especially when the measurement point is located in the ferromagnetic material. When at higher frequencies or high resistance region, the presence of the dielectric permittivity makes the apparent resistivity decrease. Therefore, in the actual data processing and inversion interpretation, for some special geological condition or at high frequency, the influences of incidence angle, displacement currents, magnetic permeability and dielectric permittivity should be taken into consideration, otherwise we cannot obtain the right conclusions.