Technical Report: Quantitative Comparison of Point Cloud Compression Algorithms

Cheng-Hao Wu,Chih-Fan Hsu,Tzu-Kuan Hung,C. Griwodz,Wei Tsang Ooi,Cheng-Hsin Hsu
2021-01-01
Abstract:With the growth of Extended Reality (XR) and capturing devices, point cloud representation has become attractive to academics and industry. Point Cloud Compression (PCC) algorithms further promote numerous XR applications that may change our daily life. However, in literature, PCC algorithms are often evaluated with heterogeneous datasets, metrics, and parameters, making the results hard to interpret. In this article, we propose an open-source benchmark platform called PCC Arena. Our platform is modularized in three aspects: PCC algorithms, point cloud datasets, and performance metrics. Users can easily extend PCC Arena in each aspect to fulfill the requirements of their experiments. To show the effectiveness of PCC Arena, we integrate seven PCC algorithms into PCC Arena along with six point cloud datasets. We then compare the algorithms on ten carefully selected metrics to evaluate the quality of the output point clouds. We further conduct a user study to quantify the user-perceived quality of rendered images that are produced by different PCC algorithms. Several novel insights are revealed in our comparison: (i) Signal Processing (SP)-based PCC algorithms are stable for different usage scenarios, but the tradeoffs between coding efficiency and quality should be carefully addressed, (ii) Neural Network (NN)-based PCC algorithms have the potentials to consume lower bitrate yet provide similar to SPbased algorithms, (iii) NN-based PCC algorithms may generate artifacts and suffer from long running time, and (iv) NN-based PCC algorithms are worth more in-depth studies as the recently proposed NN-based PCC algorithms improve on the quality and running time. We believe that PCC Arena can play an essential role in allowing engineers and researchers to better interpret and compare the performance of future PCC algorithms.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?