Abstract:In recent years, the precision of exposure assessment methods has been rapidly improved and more widely adopted in epidemiological studies. However, such methodological advancement has introduced additional heterogeneity among studies. The precision of exposure assessment has become a potential confounding factors in meta-analyses, whose impacts on effect calculation remain unclear. To explore, we conducted a meta-analysis to integrate the long- and short-term exposure effects of PM2.5, NO2, and O3 on all-cause, cardiovascular, and respiratory mortality in the Chinese population. Literature was identified through Web of Science, PubMed, Scopus, and China National Knowledge Infrastructure before August 28, 2023. Sub-group analyses were performed to quantify the impact of exposure assessment precisions and pollution levels on the estimated risk. Studies achieving merely city-level resolution and population exposure are classified as using traditional assessment methods, while those achieving sub-kilometer simulations and individual exposure are considered finer assessment methods. Using finer assessment methods, the RR (under 10 μg/m3 increment, with 95% confidence intervals) for long-term NO2 exposure to all-cause mortality was 1.13 (1.05-1.23), significantly higher (p-value = 0.01) than the traditional assessment result of 1.02 (1.00-1.03). Similar trends were observed for long-term PM2.5 and short-term NO2 exposure. A decrease in short-term PM2.5 levels led to an increase in the RR for all-cause and cardiovascular mortality, from 1.0035 (1.0016-1.0053) and 1.0051 (1.0021-1.0081) to 1.0055 (1.0035-1.0075) and 1.0086 (1.0061-1.0111), with weak between-group significance (p-value = 0.13 and 0.09), respectively. Based on the quantitative analysis and literature information, we summarized four key factors influencing exposure assessment precision under a conceptualized framework: pollution simulation resolution, subject granularity, micro-environment classification, and pollution levels. Our meta-analysis highlighted the urgency to improve pollution simulation resolution, and we provide insights for researchers, policy-makers and the public. By integrating the most up-to-date epidemiological research, our study has the potential to provide systematic evidence and motivation for environmental management.

Leveraging Individual-Level Data to Advance Air Pollution Health Risk Management

National Scale Spatiotemporal Land-Use Regression Model for PM2.5, PM10 and NO2 Concentration in China

Spatially Explicit Assessment of Heat Health Risks Using Multi-source Data:A Case Study of the Yangtze River Delta Region, China

A multi-objective model for the assessment of potential environmental risk using big data covering air quality

Spatially Explicit Mapping of Heat Health Risk Utilizing Environmental and Socioeconomic Data

Risk-based air pollutants management at regional levels

Key factors in epidemiological exposure and insights for environmental management: Evidence from meta-analysis

Developing high-resolution PM2.5 exposure models by integrating low-cost sensors, automated machine learning, and big human mobility data

Risk-Based Prioritization among Air Pollution Control Strategies in Yangtze River Delta, China

Spatial Equity of PM2.5 Pollution Exposures in High-Density Metropolitan Areas Based on Remote Sensing, LBS and GIS Data: A Case Study in Wuhan, China

Breathing in danger: Understanding the multifaceted impact of air pollution on health impacts

Air pollution and public health: emerging hazards and improved understanding of risk

PM2.5 Exposure and Health Risk Assessment Using Remote Sensing Data and GIS

Risk-Based Prioritization among Air Pollution Control Strategies in the Yangtze River Delta, China

Sustainable Urban Development: A Comprehensive Model for Assessing Health Risks from Compounded Pollution in Xi'an

Big data analytic based personalized air quality health advisory model

Survey of Ambient Air Pollution Health Risk Assessment Tools

Towards Multi-Scale Space-Time Characteristics of Air Quality and Population Exposure Risk

Examining the Potential Scaling Law in Urban PM2.5 Pollution Risks along with the Nationwide Air Environmental Effort in China

Assessing the Impact of Environmental Regulation on Ecological Risk Induced by PM2.5 Pollution: Evidence from China

Reducing Planetary Health Risks Through Short-Lived Climate Forcer Mitigation