On the Convergence to Nash Equilibrium in Retail Electricity Markets

Zheng Xu,Ye Guo,Hongbin Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/ei252483.2021.9713085

2021-01-01

Abstract:The dynamic process of retail electricity markets evolving toward their market equilibria is considered. Due to the limited number of retailers and the nature of price competition, a retail electricity market is modeled as a Bertrand competition, and the Nash Equilibrium of which is with the competitive price. This paper studies whether the retail market can actually converge to its equilibrium, how fast the convergence is, and how much profit each retailer can obtain during such a dynamic process. The model of conditional value at risk (CVaR) is adopted to model the retailers' pricing strategies with different risk-averse degrees. Several widely-used regulation measures and their impacts on the convergence process are also discussed, such as ceiling prices, adding new competitors, switching cost, and staying cost as the response from retailers. Some interesting observations include that adding new retailers may not significantly accelerate the price convergence as many expected, and that limiting the range of price variations can accelerate the convergence if retailers are risk-neutral but decelerate the process if retailers are very risk-averse. These findings will help market administrators to better understand the dynamic of retail electricity markets and tailor their regulation measures thereupon.