Low Carbohydrate Intake Before Oral Glucose-Tolerance Tests

Takashi Kaneko,Pei-Yu Wang,Masato Tawata,Akio Sato

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(05)60263-2

IF: 202.731

1998-01-01

The Lancet

Abstract:Authors' reply Sir—Keiji Yoshioka and co-workers make important comments on our report. The impairment of glucose tolerance after a restricted carbohydrate intake was invariably accompanied by an increase in the fasting plasma concentration of free fatty acids, suggesting that the impairment is associated with the Randle effect. It is possible that the effects of fatty acids on glucose metabolism may be involved in the impairment of glucose tolerance after a low carbohydrate intake. In our study, the insulinogenic index decreased after restricted carbohydrate intake, which indicates that after carbohydrate restriction proportionally less insulin is released in response to the glycaemic stimulus. Over 60 years ago, Himsworth1Himsworth HP Dietetic factor determining glucose tolerance and sensitivity to insulin of healthy men.Clin Sci. 1935; 2: 67-94Google Scholar showed, with a state-of-the-art approach, that the glucose tolerance in non-diabetic men is adversely affected by a lowered carbohydrate intake (not by an increased fat intake) before an OGTT. He found that the glucose tolerance and insulin sensitivity improved as a result of the change from a low-carbohydrate/high-fat diet to a high-carbohydrate/low-fat diet, and that the improvement was solely due to the amount of carbohydrate in the diet. We agree with the view that a high carbohydrate intake increases the insulin sensitivity. We agree with Yoshioka that an OGTT is not necessarily inferior to a fasting plasma glucose test. The scientific reason why an OGTT is judged inferior to a fasting plasma glucose test is that the OGTT is more subject to within-individual variation. In the study by Mooy and colleagues,2Mooy JM Gootenhuis PA de Vries H et al.Intra-individual variation of glucose, specific insulin and proinsulin concentrations measured by two oral glucose tolerance tests in general Caucasian population: the Hoorn Study.Diabetologia. 1996; 39: 298-305Crossref PubMed Scopus (327) Google Scholar in which OGTTs were repeated pver 2–6 weeks, the within-individual coefficients of variation were 6·4% for the fasting plasma glucose concentrations and 16·7% for the 2-h postload plasma glucose concentrations. However, Mooy and co-workers mentioned that “participants were instructed to abstain from alcohol from 17:00 hours and to fast (except for drinking water) from 22:00 hours the previous day”. As we showed in our study, one of the factors that contributed to the within-individual variation in OGTTs is the carbohydrate intake before a test. In response to Richard Baschetti, when we prepare isocaloric diets containing a fixed amount of protein, we change the contents of fat and carbohydrate simultaneously. Therefore, a high-carbohydrate diet is nothing but a low-fat diet, and conversely, a low-carbohydrate diet inevitably contains excessive amounts of fat. Thus is is difficult to differentiate the effect of a low-carbohydrate diet from that of excessive amounts of fat. The works of Swinburn and coworkers3Swinburn BA Boyce VL Bergman RN Howard BV Bogardus C Deterioration in carbohydrate metabolism and lipoprotein changes induced by modern, high fat diet in Pima Indians and Caucasians.J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1991; 73: 156-165Crossref PubMed Scopus (140) Google Scholar and Marshall and colleagues4Marshall JA Hoag S Shetterly S Hamman RF Dietary fat predicts conversion from impaired glucose tolerance to NIDDM. The San Luis Valley Diabetes Study.Diabetes Care. 1994; 17: 50-56Crossref PubMed Scopus (204) Google Scholar do not necessarily support the idea that high-fat diets deteriorate carbohydrate metabolism. The transition from a high-carbohydrate diet to a low-carbohydrate diet may partly explain the dramatic increase in the prevalence of non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus among Pima Indians over the past century. The main findings of the study by O'Dea5O'Dea K Marked improvement in carbohydrate and lipid metabolism in diabetic Australian Aborigines after temporary reversion to traditional lifestyle.Diabetes. 1984; 33: 596-603Crossref PubMed Google Scholar was the improvement in glucose tolerance in ten diabetic Aborigines after a 7-week reversion to traditional hunter-gatherer lifestyle. The lifestyle change (an increase in protein intake and decrease in energy intake) accompanied substantial weight loss. Perhaps the decreased energy intake rather than the increased protein intake improved the glucose tolerance of the diabetic Aborigines. Low carbohydrate intake and oral glucose-tolerance testsTakashi Kaneko and colleagues (July 25, p 289)1 discuss the importance of carbohydrate intake before an oral glucose-tolerance tests (OGTT). They conclude that the impaired glucose tolerance after a low-carbohydrate meal is due to the proportionally less insulin release in response to glycaemic stimulus, and that the decrease in insulin secretion is associated with the Randle effect.2 The insulinogenic index was significantly decreased after the low-carbohydrate intake, but no significant difference in the insulin concentrations before and 30 min after OGTT was found between patients on the low-carbohydrate intake and high-carbohydrate intake. Full-Text PDF Low carbohydrate intake and oral glucose-tolerance testsTakashi Kaneko and colleagues1 conclude that when an OGTT is used to classify patients' glucose tolerance as normal, impaired, or diabetic, particular attention should be paid to the carbohydrate content of their last meal. Even more attention, however, should be paid to the fat content of that meal. In fact, the impaired glucose tolerance found by Kaneko and colleagues among those patients whose last meal contained 10% carbohydrate, 25% protein, and 65% fat may actually reflect a too high fat content, not a low carbohydrate meal. Full-Text PDF