Contrast Demand on the Blackboard in Typical Secondary School Classrooms of China: Effects of Daylight Reflections on Text Legibility

Yu Bian,Jianhe Luo,Tao Luo,Tianxiang Leng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2022.111974

IF: 7.201

2022-01-01

Energy and Buildings

Abstract:A survey of visual problems in typical secondary school classrooms of China showed that poor legibility on the blackboard caused by reflections is the most reported issue that disturbs visual tasks in class. Studying the correlations between variables and the legibility of chalk writings on the blackboard, accessing the borderline threshold of contrast and revealing the effects of other variables are the priority assignments to address the problem. Based on the findings from the questionnaire survey and on-site contrast measurement, an experiment of legibility assessment was settled in a mockup classroom scenario, in where the subjective rating study about disturbance level of reflections and clarity level of texts on blackboard was carried out. 210 trials were conducted during the 10-month test, more than 3,300 sets of data were collected totally. Category rating results show that 63% of all ratings could sort as disturbed. Four variables including luminance contrast between white and black portions of the board, vertical eye illuminance (EV), etc. are analyzed against the ratings of clarity level. It can be concluded from this study that: 1- Disturbance level of daylight reflections has a linear correlation with the legibility level of the texts on the blackboard. 2- The seat far from glazing and in the front row is the most disturbing position in a typical secondary classroom. 3- The dominant factor of legibility is luminance contrast, and the borderline threshold of good legibility is 1.30. 4- No evidence shows EV has a strong correlation with legibility level of then contents on a blackboard.