The Antecedents and Consequences of Corporate Green Innovation:A Meta-analytic Review
WU Jianzu,CHEN Zhiyu
2023-01-01
Abstract:In the context of carbon peak, carbon neutrality, and high-quality development requirements, firms are under pressure of green transformation. Green innovation is an essential tool for green transformation.Through green innovation, firms can take more social responsibility, reduce environmental damage and achieve sustainable development while maintaining economic growth. Green innovation has the characteristics of high risk and slow return. Furthermore, both negative and positive externalities are linked with environmental degradation and knowledge spillover in the context of green innovation. Finally, there are doubts about whether green innovation can achieve a win-win situation regarding economic and environmental performance. Therefore, existing studies on the antecedent and consequence of green innovation have not reached consistent conclusions. The research on the antecedents, repercussions, and boundary conditions of corporate green innovation can better support meaningful green innovation activities by firms and realize economic, social, national strategic, and future values. This research examines the internal and external drivers of corporate green innovation at the levels of the external organizational environment, organizational resources and capabilities, and executive team, as well as the impact of green innovation on economic and environmental performance, to assist firms in establishing green orientation and better responding to current challenges and opportunities.This research explores the antecedent and consequence variables of green innovation using 248248 studies from 91 empirical research papers in English and Chinese as a meta-analysis sample. It analyzes the moderating role of data sources and sample countries. The results of the meta-analysis revealed that（1） environmental regulation（r=0.273）, stakeholders（r=0.344）, and environmental uncertainty（r=0.106） at the level of the organization’s external environment, redundant resources（r=0.348）, organizational culture（r=0.409）, social capital（r=0.412）,resource acquisition capacity（r=0.364）, resource utilization capability（r=0.295）, and R＆D capability（r=0.415）,and executive team perception（r=0.457） at the executive team level are highly positively associated with corporate green innovation;（2） corporate green innovation is highly positively associated with financial performance（r=0.205） and environmental performance（r=0.613）;（3） data sources and sample countries are highly correlated with innovation has a moderating effect on the relationship between innovation and antecedent and consequence variables.Based on the collation and summarization of existing empirical studies, this research draws the following conclusions:（1） it proves that factors at the level of the organization’s external environment, organizational resources and capabilities, and the executive team can effectively promote corporate green innovation, but the executive team generates the most significant driving effect, which to a certain extent provides more theoretical basis for establishing a social green meaningful orientation and guiding firms to carry out meaningful innovation;（2） it proves that corporate green innovation can achieve the win-win goal of financial performance and environmental performance, which again emphasizes the vital role of green innovation in protecting the environment and achieving high-quality development;（3） it finds that there are differences in the effects of different data sources and sample countries on the relationship between green innovation and antecedent and consequence variables,which to a certain extent explains the inconsistent findings of existing studies and provides a specific theoretical basis for subsequent research. In addition, this research also defines the concept of green innovation and classifies green innovation at different levels.For future research on green innovation, this research has the following three suggestions:（1） pay attention to the influence of the executive team on green innovation. This research demonstrates the crucial driving role of the executive team level on green innovation. Still, the existing literature has only a few studies with the executive team as the entry point. Future research on green innovation drivers can be promoted by cutting more from the executive team level;（2） using methods such as machine learning to conduct more accurate analysis. This research finds that data sources affect the relationship between green innovation and antecedent and consequence variables.By optimizing data measurement methods and reducing the influence of data sources on research results, more convincing conclusions can be drawn to guide corporate green innovation practices better;（3） research on green innovation is conducted from different dimensions of green innovation. This research summarizes the green innovation concepts in the existing literature and finds that various studies focus on varying levels of green innovation and mainly focus on the green innovation behavior of firms. Therefore, future research from different levels of green innovation will benefit from exploring green innovation mechanisms more comprehensively.