Abstract:To alleviate congestion, many Chinese cities have adopted either one of the two car ownership policies, namely, license plate auction or license plate lottery, to limit the number of cars on the road. In an effort to address the criticism associated with administering a single car ownership policy, cities are considering the possibility of carrying out both policies simultaneously, so that residents can choose whether to pay for the license plate through an auction or get it for free from a lottery but with a longer wait time. We study residents' preferences toward the two car ownership policies when both are administered at the same time, a problem that has not been investigated in the literature. We then examine the influence of car ownership policies on the choice of electric cars, which is also new to the literature. Using data collected from a stated preference survey, we estimate mixed logit models using the hierarchical Bayes approach based on the Markov Chain Monte Carlo method. Results show that strong preference heterogeneity exists in respondents' policy choice. We proceed to conduct regression analysis to explain the variations in the preferences toward license plate auction and electric cars. Our main results include: (1) We find that prospective car buyers in Beijing and Shanghai are willing to bid 27,000 yuan and 49,000 yuan to shorten their wait time to get car license plates by one year, respectively; (2) The subsidy to electric cars can be reduced by 102,000 yuan in Beijing and 85,000 yuan in Shanghai if the wait time for an electric car license plate is shortened by one year; (3) Car buyers in favor of license plate auction are those who are from high-income households, who are not buying their first cars, and who are below 30 or above 40 years old; and (4) When promoting the adoption of electric cars, policy incentives, such as making it easier to obtain an electric car license plate and providing attractive subsidies, are as important as the technological advancement electric car manufacturers strive to make, such as improving the driving range of electric cars.

How License Plate Lotteries Affect Car Purchase Decisions: Evidence from Chinaas Auto Market and the Lab

The Selection Effect of Quota Rationing Mechanisms on Sales Distribution: the Convergence of Auction and Lottery

Car Ownership Policies in China: Preferences of Residents and Influence on the Choice of Electric Cars

An examination of the impact of socio-demographic factors on the demand for sports lotteries in China

Analysis of Cars' Commuting Behavior under License Plate Restriction Policy: a Case Study in Hangzhou, China

A Comparisonstudyof the Effectiveness of the License Plate Distributionpolicies in Beijing and Shanghai:Based on the Analysis of Car Idleness and Residents’ Satisfaction Chinese Full Text

Social Benefit Evaluation of Policies on Vehicle Plate Restriction in Urban China

Buying a Wealthy Dream: Determinants of Rural Residents' Lottery Purchase Behavior in China

Effects of Vehicle Restriction Policies: Analysis Using License Plate Recognition Data in Langfang, China

The Black Market for Beijing License Plates

Vehicle Quota System and Its Impact on the Chinese Auto Markets: A Tale of Two Cities

What Drives Demand for State-Run Lotteries? Evidence and Welfare Implications

License Bidding – Sunk Costs that Matter

Determinants of city-level private car ownership: Effect of vehicle regulation policies and the relative price

Limited Liability and High Bids in English Auctions

Assessing Motor Vehicle Quota Policies in China: Social Welfare Perspective

The impact of different incentive policies on new energy vehicle demand in China's gigantic cities

Lottery in Economic Law

Income distribution, implementation sequence, and equity in auto ownership rationing

Factors Influencing Purchase of Electric Vehicles in China

Lottery preference, short-sale constraint, and the salience effect: Evidence from China