Abstract:Poorer citizens generally participate less in politics; at the same time, the income-based gap in participation is not the same across democracies. Whereas in Denmark in 1977 turnout among poorer citizens was 6 percentage points higher than among wealthier ones, in the United States in 1988 the gap is reversed: turnout among wealthier Americans is 31 percentage points higher than among their poorer peers. Existing attempts at understanding the sources of this variation point to macro-level factors, such as compulsory voting, ballot complexity, or income inequality (Gallego, 2015; Solt, 2008). Though important, we argue that existing accounts aren't successful in explaining temporal variation in this participation gap, over periods of time in which the institutional framework is stable. We propose instead a largely neglected, yet plausible, reason for why a differential effect of income on political participation exists: the characteristics of the welfare state. In addition to providing resources relevant to participation, welfare state arrangements also create political constituencies that can be mobilized around a shared goal by political entrepreneurs. Building on Schneider and Makszin's (2014) education-based analysis we inductively develop, with the use of Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA), various welfare regime types that condition patterns of income-based participatory inequality in democracies. These are produced based on an original data set of roughly 150 merged surveys from 19 OECD members, between 1960 and 2010. We label these types the supportive and mobilizing welfare regimes, along with their non-mobilizing and non-supportive counterparts. These welfare state regimes correspond to different mechanisms through which welfare state characteristics shape participatory patterns: (1) resource endowments available to individuals for participation and (2) unions' and parties' ability to politically mobilize and inform their members. We complement our aggregate-level QCA analysis with individual-level tests of these hypothesized mechanisms. Relying on six cross-national survey programs, such as the European Social Survey or the Comparative Study of Electoral Systems, we find consistent support for the mobilization-based mechanisms, while revealing mixed evidence that they also spill over into attitudinal factors which underpin participation. Only weaker evidence is found for our resource-based mechanisms. Overall, our results indicate the effect of welfare state characteristics on political participation gaps in advanced industrial democracies. Welfare state reforms, and in particular retrenchment, are likely to have (damaging) consequences for democracy.

What causes polarized stagnation, corporate economy, or welfare state?: Insights from new development economics

Development Economics and the issues of poverty and social inequalities

Theoretical Visions Versus Policymaking Realities? Searching For The Logical Grounds Of Expansion And Retrenchment Arguments In Studies On Nordic Social Policy Models From The 1960s To The 2000s

The Dynamics of Disparity: A Comprehensive Analysis of the Causes and Consequences of Income and Wealth Inequality and Policy Interventions for Mitigation

Political economy and structural transformation: democracy, regulation and public investment

Analytical utility of periodizing capitalist history: Neoliberalism, social welfare spending, and income inequality in the United States

The economic and cultural dimensions of unequal policy representation

Welfare States Matter for Democracy: Income-based Participatory Inequality in Post-WW 2 Western Democracies

Polarization Lost: Exploring the Decline of Ideological Voting in Congress after the Gilded Age

Enterprise and Welfare States: a Comparative Perspective

Institutional Change in Advanced Political Economies

Welfare Catch-up and Growth Trap: Lessons from Latin America

Zooming in or zooming out: Energy strategy, developmental parity and regional entrepreneurial dynamism

Polarization under rising inequality and economic decline

Economic Development Pattern and Trade Imbalance: Comparing the U.S. with East Asia

Paradise Gained and Lost: Shared Prosperity in East Asian Welfare Production Regimes

"Welfare Catch-up",Government Malfunction and Economic Stagnation

A Theory of Social Infrastructure and Economic Development

Aggregate Demand Externalities, Income Distribution, and Wealth Inequality

Inequality, Identity, and Partisanship: How redistribution can stem the tide of mass polarization

Institutions Do Not Rule: Reassessing the Driving Forces of Economic Development