Value of Public Real-Time Crime Information: Evidence from Bike Share Detouring Behavior

Xiangjun Hong,Jing-Sheng Jeannette Song,Xin Tian,Shouyang Wang,Tian Wu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4003361
2021-01-01
SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract:Bike sharing is widely recognized as an effective means to promote air quality and public health in modern cities. However, a significant barrier in its implementation is the threat of criminal activities during the cycling journey. Beginning on February 24, 2016, when the New York Police opened crime-related statistics to the public, cyclists can access up-to-date crime statistics in every police precinct through an App on smartphones and wearables. In this paper, we use this trigger event to empirically analyze how useful this information is for the cyclists to detour to strategically avoid crime hot spots and for the criminals to strategically conduct crime in the previously unpopular areas. Our study utilizes two public data sets from New York City: the crime history in different districts and the public bike share usage. We also collect the default routing data from Google Maps. We find that subscribers of a bike share App indeed pay attention to the information about crime and detour accordingly. The information disclosure of crime information can lead to a 1.64% decrease in crime. After accounting for the criminals’ strategic reactions, we still found a positive net crime-moderation effect. The data showed a 0.5% reduction in the crime rate once cyclists defended themselves by detouring, especially on streets with moderate crime. These findings demonstrate the value of public disclosure of real-time information about safety and shed light on how governments can determine which data to share to the public in building smart cities.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?