The Effects of Behavioral Distinctiveness Versus Verbal Distinctiveness on Firm Performance

Hai Guo,Yang Li,Chao Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2020.20033abstract
2020-01-01
Academy of Management Proceedings
Abstract:How distinctiveness impacts firm performance, the central question related to optimal distinctiveness theory, has been discussed by many scholars. However, there is a lack of uniform empirical evidence. In this study, we synchronize the multiple distinctiveness employed in optimal distinctiveness (OD) theory introducing the notion of verbal distinctiveness and behavioral distinctiveness, and explore their underlying different mechanisms on conflicting pressure of legitimacy and competition. Consistent with our theoretical framework, results combining a text analysis of 29011 annual reports with the financial data from 3303 listed companies in China show an inverted U-shaped effect of verbal distinctiveness on firm performance but a U-shaped effect of behavioral distinctiveness. Form the orchestrating perspective of OD theory, we further examine the effects of decoupling distinctiveness—the deviation between verbal distinctiveness and behavioral distinctiveness, and find a negative impact on firm performance.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?