Chine brune ou Chine verte? Les dilemmes de l'Etat-Parti (Brown China or Green China? The Dilemmas of the Party-State) [Book Review]
Benoît Vermander,Jean-Paul Maréchal
2008-01-01
China Perspectives
Abstract:Benoit Vermander, Chine brune ou Chine verte? Les dilemmes de l'Etat-Parti, (Brown or Green ? The Dilemmas of the Party-State) Paris, Les Presses de Sciences Po, 2007, 212 pp.Three decades after its brilliantly successful conversion to market economy, and seven years after its entry into the World Trade Organisation, is now confronted with intermeshed social and environmental threats that could well short-circuit a portion of its patiently built achievements. The leadership's decisions in the next few years could as easily plunge into a structural crisis as impart a new dynamism, says Benoit Vermander. China, he says, is caught between two paradigms: brown China and green China. The first term stands for a strategy of social control, pursuit of high growth rates whatever the social and ecological cost, and immediate maximisation on the international arena of the advantages linked to the country's rise. The second term denotes political liberalisation and promotion of sustainable as well as international cooperation.Naturally, these options are poles apart, two ideal types that delimit the area of possibilities as much as they define the government's plans. Equally, there can be a whole range of possible choices in between. But these are difficult choices for the authorities, who have to find an optimum formula between internal tensions and external constraints, or in other words simultaneously (and ideally) pursue harmonious society (retermed scientific development since 2007) at home and (or development) internationally. On this choice depends China's future, but also that of the world, given the Middle Kingdom's central role on the global arena.Internal tensions stem notably from rising inequality and ecological crisis. A 2006 report by the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences said 10 percent of the richest families in held nearly half (45 percent) of private wealth, while the poorest 10 percent held a mere 2 percent. In 2005, the richest decile of the population enjoyed incomes 12 times those of the poorest decile. In addition to these inequalities, of a magnitude comparable to those in Latin America, there are a number of problems linked to land distribution, health, edumajor cation, and working conditions (4,700 deaths in mines every year). As for ecological problems, they affect all strata and all milieus (water, air, and soil). Some figures are worth noting: each year outside air pollution causes between 350,000 and 400,000 deaths, polluted water claims 60,000 lives, and by 2020 there will be some 20 million ecological refugees. is home to five of the world's most polluted cities, 70 to 80 percent of cancer cases diagnosed in Beijing are linked to the environment, and the capital's water table has fallen by 37 metres in 40 years. And there were 161 serious ecological accidents in 2006. The list goes on.It thus comes as no surprise to learn that in 2005 there were 87,000 protests involving more than 100 people, of which 50,000 were over pollution. Along with these internal problems are those of managing economic might on the international scene. How to ease several years of uninterrupted double-digit growth rates while keeping weaknesses at bay, and without engaging in potentially ruinous trade conflicts or strategic rivalries? The Chinese doctrine is expressed in two words: rise or development (this second formulation being deemed less aggressive). Through this expression popularised in 2003, the authorities were signalling the following action guidelines: identifying Chinese interests as being part of those of developing countries (at least in precept), holding fast to the non-interference principle, proclaiming the peaceful character of Chinese culture, and supporting multilateralism as a means of repelling antagonism to China's rise. …