The Chinese Milk Powder Crisis: Implications for Supply Chain Quality Management

Xiande Zhao,Yina Li,Barbara B. Flynn,Stephen Ng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2012.11520abstract

2012-01-01

Academy of Management Proceedings

Abstract:We examine the supply chain quality management implications of a product harm crisis. Using an in-depth case study of the recent recalls of melamine-tainted dairy products in China, we examine the role that supply chain governance structure and quality assurance system played in causing the quality problems and handling the subsequent recalls. Based on a comparison between the Chinese dairy companies experiencing product harm crises and those that did not, we find that supply chains with a more vertically integrated, better coordinated governance structure were less likely to experience a product harm crisis. Further analysis, using long-term event study, revealed that the stock market reaction was negative toward the companies found to have melamine in their products, but positive towards the companies that were not found to have melamine in their milk products. The companies experienced different severity of cumulative abnormal returns, in terms of negative impact and recovery speed, due to differences in their supply chain governance structure and quality assurance systems. The results are discussed in terms of total cost of quality and implications for supply chain quality management. Future research directions are suggested in the areas of supply chain quality management and consumer reactions to alternative product recall strategies.