A Snapshot of the Catalysis Research in the Netherlands As Carried out Within the Netherlands Institute for Catalysis Research (NIOK)
Joost N. H. Reek,Floris P. J. T. Rutjes,Emiel J. M. Hensen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/cctc.202300928
IF: 4.5
2023-01-01
ChemCatChem
Abstract:The importance of catalysis has been recognized a long time ago and the first industrial application stems from the early nineteenth century. The number of newly developed catalytic processes steadily increased in the twentieth century, and the field progressed in terms of knowledge to a tremendous level. It is save to conclude that without industrial catalytic processes life as we know it would look rather different, if only you imagine the widespread applications that require polymers, the production of fertilizers to feed the world, and the catalytic systems we have invented to prepare complex molecules that are required in the production of pharmaceuticals. Despite all progress, there are still major challenges left. Current chemical processes are mostly based on fossil feedstock and energy, and the transformation to a circular chemical industry that no longer requires such non-renewable resources is without doubt the biggest. It involves the use of biomass, CO2 and waste as feedstock. This transition also provides opportunities for the redesign of materials such that they are more suited for reuse in a circular economy. All this needs to be increasingly driven by renewable energy for which new catalytic processes remain indispensable. Traditionally, the field of catalysis has been divided in homogeneous, heterogeneous and biocatalysis, with each of them having their strengths and weaknesses. Over the years these fields have become much closer and gradually merged as witnessed by e. g. artificial enzymes, i. e. enzymes with synthetic active sites for new-to-nature catalytic reactions, and grafting of organometallic complexes on support to heterogenize complexes. Next to this, tremendous progress has been made in the development of computational and spectroscopic tools to understand the fundamentals of catalysis. We are proud that all these expertise are represented in NIOK, the Netherlands Institute for Catalysis Research. NIOK unites the researchers active in catalysis at Dutch universities. As a nationwide graduate school, NIOK fosters the advancement of both higher education and research and stimulates collaboration between scientists of different disciplines and universities. NIOK was established in 1991 by the major catalysis groups of seven Dutch universities, while later also Radboud University Nijmegen and Wageningen University became member. NIOK has also been recognized by the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences (KNAW). Importantly, NIOK has been supported by the industrial advisory board VIRAN, which consists of members from Dutch and multinational industries involved in many aspects of catalysis. The structure of the NIOK organization has stimulated collaboration between research groups and collaborations between industrial and academic partners. As a result, catalysis research in the Netherlands flourishes, has opened up the borders between disciplines in the past decades, and has strong connections to various industries facilitating the societal application of new scientific findings. In the current virtual issue “the NIOK feature” hosted by ChemCatChem, EurJIC and EurJOC, these aspects are reflected in the contributions of which many are based on collaboration between different research groups. Heterogeneous catalysis is traditionally strongly represented in the Dutch community, and this is reflected in some of the contributions. The Lefferts group reported a kinetic analysis of ammonia synthesis using various metal-supported catalysts (on MgO) in a plasma reactor. The Weckhuysen group described the use of silicon-rich waste for the preparation of zeolites. The effect of hydrothermal treatment and the impact of impurities on waste-derived zeolites were investigated, and the materials were used in methanol to study hydrocarbon conversion. The group of de Jongh studied the effect of nickel nanoparticle size, supported on carbon, on methanation of CO2. The effect of the size of copper nanoparticles on the hydrogenation of 1,3-butadiene was reported by the same group. The same group also explored the size-dependent activity and selectivity of SiO2-supported copper nanoparticles in the gas phase hydrogenation of 1,3-butadiene, obtaining up to a four-fold increase in activity and almost full selectivity by going from 2 to 7–10 nm particles. The group of Führer and Bitter, in collaboration with Hensen and Tromp, reported the effect of the oxygen groups at the support on the oxidation catalysis of glucose using platinum particles. When the particles are small, the glucose adsorption is hindered by these oxygen groups from the support. The Pescarmona group described the binder free synthesis of zeolites, which were explored in the Friedel-Crafts acylation of anisole. Shiju and co-workers explored MXenes as a new family of 2D carbides as catalyst for the thermal dehydrogenation of butane, favoring the formation of olefins. The Heeres group reported a series of supported MoO3 catalysts and their exploration in the demethoxylation of guaiacol, which is present in bioliquids derived from lignocellulosic biomass. The Hensen group reported a novel silica-alumina catalyst for the Diels-Alder cycloaddition of 1,5-dimethylfuran and ethylene as a new route for the fabrication of p-xylene based on biobased feedstock. The same group also reported the synthesis of nanocrystalline mordenite zeolite materials with improved benzene alkylation properties. The group of de Jong described silica-supported silver nanoparticles, which are highly dispersed with a narrow size distribution, as catalysts in the oxidation of CO. In many NIOK contributions spectroscopic investigations are combined with catalyst development, aiming for more detailed insight in the mechanistic aspects of the operation. The Roithová group reported the application of a flow reactor coupled to an electrospray mass spectrometer to study the reactivity of non-heme iron-acyl-nitrenoid complexes, producing qualitative kinetic data and information on reaction intermediates of hydrogen atom transfer reactions. The Browne group studied the mechanism of manganese catalysts for oxidation catalysis by Raman spectroscopy, using 18O-labeled oxygen. These studies show that the same reactive intermediate is active in alkene and alcohol oxidation catalysis. The Hamlin and Bickelhaupt group performed high level quantum chemical analysis, showing that C(spn)-halogen bonds are easier to activate by a palladium catalyst when the halogen is larger, due to a difference in activation strain and a more favorable electrostatic attraction between the palladium catalyst and the substrate. The Meirer and Weckhuysen group evaluated the microporosity of catalyst supports by X-ray and electron microscopy, revealing their accessibility during early reaction stages, as well as the kinetics of a catalyst as important factors that control the degree of sectioning in silica-supported olefin polymerization catalysts during ethylene polymerization. Reek, Tromp and Korstanje highlighted detailed studies on the nickel-catalyzed cross-coupling reaction in which kinetic analysis is combined with a series of spectroscopic techniques including UV-vis, EPR, XANES and EXAFS, providing insights into the competition between productive catalysis and deleterious pathways (comproportionation and protodehalogenation) in the commonly proposed self-sustained NiI/NiIII catalytic cycle. A collaboration of the groups of Rutjes, Feiters and Tessari explored the chelation modes of iridium hyperpolarization catalysts containing bidentate amino acid ligands with the use of DFT and NMR studies, leading to a better understanding of the detection and quantification of amino acids by hyperpolarization NMR in complex mixtures such as body fluids. The development of homogeneous catalysts requires knowledge of inorganic and organometallic chemistry, and this expertise is also available in the NIOK consortium. The Bouwman group in collaboration with the Guerra group reported the preparation of novel cobalt complexes based on selenium and sulfur-functionalized multidentate ligands. Comparison of these complexes revealed that the cobalt(III)-selenolate compounds are less stable as a result of the ligand-field strength of selenium being smaller than that of sulfur. De Broere group reported the synthesis and characterization of Ru3(μ-CO)3(CO)5-type cluster complexes bound to a dinucleating PNNP type pincer ligand. These ligands can undergo deprotonation concomitant with dearomatization of its naphthyridine core, however, there is no indication that the reaction with H2 proceeds via a pathway involving metal-ligand cooperativity. Naturally, there has always been a strong component of bioinspiration and supramolecular chemistry within NIOK. This is reflected in the contribution from the Hetterscheid group, who highlighted the biochemistry of the multicopper enzyme laccase which is an excellent catalyst for redox reactions. Insights in how these enzymes operate may provide a blueprint for the design of synthetic catalysts with a similar performance. The Roelfes group reviewed how biocatalysts construct aryl-alkyl and aryl-acyl bonds, which may act as a source of inspiration. Several examples of such enzymes, as well as Friedel-Crafts artificial enzymes and DNA catalysts, were discussed with a focus on the production of useful products, the mechanism and approaches for engineering. The Elemans and Nolte group reported porphyrin cage compounds that can be used for host-guest chemistry, and 113Cd NMR and UV-vis spectroscopy, and X-ray structure analysis revealed details on the binding behavior of various charged guest molecules. A similar manganese (III) porphyrin cage was studied by the same group in collaboration with Roithová. Ion mobility mass spectrometry revealed that a manganese (III) porphyrin cage reacts with the oxidant iodosylbenzene to form an inside iodosylbenzene complex, which is converted into a manganese(V)oxo complex in which the oxo group is located inside the cage to further react with alkenes to form epoxides. When the cage is blocked by methyl groups, the reaction with iodosylbenzene and the formation of the manganese(V)oxo complex occurs at the outside of the cage. The Reek group reported rhodium catalysts for hydroformylation utilized with anion binding sites. The origin of the regioselectivity in hydroformylation using substrate orientation in DIMphos-supported rhodium complexes was studied by DFT calculations, and appeared more complicated than anticipated. It was shown that the substrate binding event itself plays an important role in determining large energy differences between crucial isomers that lead two the different regio-isomeric products. Following ditopic substrate binding, the product forming pathways leading to the minor isomeric product are particularly disfavored by the steric repulsion between the ditopically bound substrate and the apical coordinated CO ligand. The Bonnet group reported a novel amphiphilic cobalt(II) polypyridyl complex (CoC12) and an amphiphilic ruthenium photosensitizer (RuC12) that were immobilized on liposomes to perform photocatalytic H2 generation. It was found that the CoC12 is photostable, while the optimized turnover number (161) was limited by the decomposition of the ruthenium-based photosensitizer. The fields of photocatalysis and electrocatalysis are becoming increasingly important in the context of the electrification of the chemical industry and the challenges for energy storage, and as such these types of studies are also carried out by NIOK researchers. Altomare reported the use of amorphous NiCu films on TiO2 nanotube arrays as photocatalysts for hydrogen evolution. Flox and Susarrey Arce report pulsed laser deposition (PLD) of monoclinic (m)-WO3 on graphitic felt electrodes (GF), for the application in redox flow batteries. Saedy and Kortlever demonstrated the preparation of core-shell Pt−Pd catalysts which were explored in CO2 electrocatalytic reduction reaction. The Kortlever groups also explored the effects of microstructure versus applied potential during electrochemical CO2 reduction on polycrystalline copper foils, and demonstrated the dominant effect of the applied potential over microstructural properties during catalysis. The group of Costa Figueiredo reported Cu-based catalysts for the electrosynthesis of ammonia from nitrate, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy demonstrated that Cu(0) is the active phase during catalysis. Van der Stam and Weckhuysen reported the preparation of bimetallic Cu−Pd electrocatalysts from industrial residues. The materials were used for the electrochemical conversion of CO2, and spectroscopic studies revealed the interplay between the reduced Pd and Cu sites, resulting in higher CO formation. De Jongh and Ngene described the ligand-free preparation of silver nanoparticles by using acid surface groups. The materials showed enhanced performance in the electrocatalytic reduction of CO2 to CO. The Mul group explored the Kolbe electrolysis, which is the decarboxylation of carboxylic acids, in the context of deacidification of pyrolysis oil. In this study, Kolbe electrolysis of acetic acid was investigated and a change in product selectivity from ethane to methanol was demonstrated by accumulation of (bi)carbonate in the vicinity of the electrode surface. Photocatalysis has also attracted increasing attention from the synthetic community. The Noël group reported the photocatalytic ATRA reaction mediated by Bi2O3, which can be accelerated through the addition of certain amines. The key role of the amines is to ensure a thermodynamic stabilization of BimBrn-solvato complex as the homogeneous photocatalytic active species, resulting in a faster and more effective ATRA process. Needless to say, these contributions provide only a flavor of the research activities performed by the NIOK community. We are proud of this special issue showcasing the strength and importance of catalysis research in the Netherlands, which we hope will contribute to a more sustainable future for society. Joost Reek is full professor (chair supramolecular catalysis) since 2006, and distinguished faculty professor since 2017 at the University of Amsterdam. He is co-founder (and currently scientific director) of InCatT (innovative catalyst technologies), a spin-off company that was launched in 2009. In 2013 he was elected as a new member of the Royal Holland Society of Sciences and Humanities (KHMW), and in 2015 he was elected member of the KNAW (Royal Dutch academy of sciences). With more than 400 scientific papers published on different topics, mostly related to catalysis, he has reached a H-index of 80. The research performed in the past 25 years is broadly centered around homogenous catalysis and supramolecular chemistry. We develop new catalytic processes based on 1) rational ligand design in transition metal catalysis 2) Supramolecular catalysis 3) Bio-inspired catalysis. We study crucial aspects of catalysis, including activity, selectivity, stability and recycle-ability of the catalyst. In the past 15 years, part of the research has been focused on solar to fuel devices based on molecular components. In this context, we developed new catalyst for water oxidation and proton reduction, and we can drive these uphill reactions using light as the energy source by combining them with the proper chromophores. More recently, we are also exploring the use of some of our supramolecular concepts, including cages, for catalysis in and gene delivery to living cells. Since 2016 he is the scientific director of NIOK, the Netherlands Institute for Catalysis Research. Floris Rutjes received his PhD in the area of organic synthesis from the University of Amsterdam in 1993 under the supervision of Profs. Speckamp and Hiemstra. After a post-doctoral stay with Prof. Nicolaou on natural product synthesis at The Scripps Research Institute (La Jolla, USA) and an assistant-professorship at the University of Amsterdam, he became full professor and head of the department of synthetic organic chemistry at Radboud University (Nijmegen, NL) in 1999. His research interests comprise sustainable synthesis methodology, developing biologically active small molecules, new bioorthogonal click-probes for chemical ligation, and continuous flow synthesis in microreactors. He has received several awards including the Gold Medal of the Royal Netherlands Chemical Society (2002), the AstraZeneca Award for Research in Organic Chemistry (2003), and in 2008 was announced ‘Most entrepreneurial scientist of the Netherlands’. Rutjes served as President of the Netherlands Chemical Society (2016–2019), is an elected member of the Academia Europaea and in 2020 became Knight of the Order of the Netherlands Lion. Currently, he is Director of the Institute for Molecules and Materials (IMM) at Radboud University and President of the European Chemical Society (EuChemS). Emiel Hensen received his PhD degree in Catalysis in 2000 from Eindhoven University of Technology, The Netherlands. Between 2000 and 2008, he worked at the University of Amsterdam, Shell Research in Amsterdam and Eindhoven University of Technology on several topics in the field of heterogeneous catalysis. Since July 2009, he is full professor of Inorganic Materials and Catalysis at TU/e. He was a visiting professor at the Katholieke Universiteit Leuven (Belgium, 2001–2016) and at Hokkaido University (Japan, 2016). He is principal investigator and management team member of the gravitation program Multiscale Catalytic Energy Conversion, elected member of the Advanced Research Center Chemical Building Blocks Consortium and chairman of the Netherlands Institute for Catalysis Research (NIOK). Hensen was head of the department of Chemical Engineering and Chemistry of Eindhoven University of Technology from 2016–2020. Hensen received Veni, Vidi, Vici and Casmir grant awards from the Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research. His main interests are in mechanism of heterogeneous catalysis combining experimental and computation studies. He has published over 625 papers, 20 book chapters and 7 patents.