The Achilles' Heel of Social Entrepreneurial Strategy: Social Versus Economic Performance

Charlotte Ren,Chao Guo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2018.18671abstract
2018-01-01
Abstract:Social entrepreneurial ventures aspire to generate both social and economic value. Yet their ability to actually do so has hardly been theoretically justified or empirically validated. We address this gap by examining how a social venture’s strategic choices that lead to stronger social performance tend to negatively affect economic performance, and vice versa. We focus on two choices related to the fundamentals of business strategy: competitive scope of activities and source of competitive advantage. Using a unique panel data of charter schools in Texas (1997-2007), we find evidence that both a broader scope and a differentiation strategy improve a school’s academic performance, but reduce its economic performance. The trade-offs from the opposing effects become even more pronounced in a more turbulent environment: the positive impact of differentiation on academic performance would vanish, whereas the negative impact of scope expansion and differentiation on economic performance would increase even further. Our findings provide insights on how theories of strategic management and the public and nonprofit management literature can illuminate the challenges of performance in social entrepreneurship.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?