A Resource Perspective on Social Network and Job Outcomes: A Meta-Analytic Study

Yuen Lam Bavik,Xiang Zhou,Jason D. Shaw
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2018.13543abstract
2018-01-01
Academy of Management Proceedings
Abstract:In recent years, there has been increasing research on the effect of social network on job outcomes. However, our knowledge about the theoretical underpinnings of the network-outcome linkage remains limited. In addition, inconsistencies exist among the empirical findings and theoretical arguments yielded from this body of research. With data from 177 independent studies (kcorr = 310, N = 408,090 for the brokerage-job outcome relationship; kcorr = 464, N = 594,147 for the centrality-job outcome relationship; kcorr = 35, N = 6,663 for the brokerage-resource relationship; kcorr = 146, N = 32,737 for the centrality-resource relationship), we theorize and meta-analytically examine the explanatory roles of resource accumulation and resource depletion in the relationship between two forms of network position (brokerage and centrality) and two major job outcomes: job performance and career success. Our results show that, although network centrality is beneficial for promoting job performance and career success through resource accumulation, it can also hurt job performance through resource depletion. Further, brokerage is found to increase job performance mainly through protecting individuals from resource depletion. We also examine the contextual moderators that may potentially influence the implications of network positions to job outcomes. Our findings provide an integrative view of the differential role of brokerage and centrality in affecting individual employee effectiveness and pave the way for future research.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?