Argumentative Discourse in Contemporary China

Wu Peng,Xu Cihua

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1075/jaic.00002.pen

2017-01-01

Abstract:Preview this article: Argumentative discourse in contemporary China, Page 1 of 1 < Previous page | Next page > /docserver/preview/fulltext/jaic.00002.pen-1.gif

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Cultural Discourse Studies: Researching Chinese Theory, Methods and Topics (2nd Edition) Cultural Discourse Studies: Researching Chinese Theory, Methods and Topics (2nd Edition), by Shi-Xu, Peking University Press, 2022, US$10.86, 330 Pp.

Xitao Hu,Le Cheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17544750.2023.2285986

IF: 3.698

2023-01-01

Chinese Journal of Communication

Abstract:Click to increase image sizeClick to decrease image size Disclosure statementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).Additional informationFundingThis work was supported by the major project of the National Social Science Foundation under Grant 20ZDA062.Notes on contributorsXitao HuXitao Hu is Research Fellow in the Institute of Cross-cultural and Regional Studies, Schoolof International Studies, Zhejiang University. His research fields include (socio-)semiotics,digital economy, legal discourse and corpus linguistics.Le ChengDr Le Cheng a Qiushi Distinguished Professor of Zhejiang University, Guanghua Distinguished Professor of Guanghua Law School, Executive Dean of International Strategy and Law, Professor of School of Cyber Science and Technology, and Professor of School of International Studies, Zhejiang University. He is the Editor-in-Chief of International Journal of Legal Discourse (De Gruyter), Editor-in-Chief of International Journal of Digital Law and Governance (De Gruyter), and former Co-Editor of Social Semiotics (Francis & Taylor), editorial member of some indexed journals like Pragmatics & Society, and Semiotica.
On The Contemporary Construction Of The Chinese System Of Academic Discourse

Wu Xiaoming

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02529203.2012.702938

2012-01-01

Social Sciences in China

Abstract:As an important academic issue, the contemporary construction of the Chinese system of academic discourse has attracted increasing attention in recent years. Questions needing further reflection and exploration are: What does the genesis and expansion of this topic actually mean? Within what horizon can we reveal its fundamental nature and draw further conclusions? What intellectual task will be presented to us in the course of fixing its direction? An in-depth probe into these questions, that is, the core issue in the contemporary construction of the Chinese system of academic discourse, is how contemporary academic discourse can enter deep into the specific content ushered in by our historical practice, so that this content can be truly grasped intellectually and studied academically.
Exploring the Cyber Governance Discourse: A Perspective from China

Chunhui Wang,Le Cheng,Jiamin Pei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/ijld-2020-2025

2020-01-01

International Journal of Legal Discourse

Abstract:This study aims to examine China's approach to the cyber governance, especially the discourse of Internet information, through a detailed investigation of the Provision on Ecological Governance of Internet Information Content. The findings in this study indicate that China's approach to the governance of Internet information possesses the following essential features: the clarification of the dialectical relationship between Internet freedom and order, the unification of carrying forward positive energy and restraining negative information, the people-oriented and bottom-up participatory approach to the ecological governance of Internet information, as well as the strictly prohibitive conducts of three key administrative counterparts. The underlying reasons for choosing such an ecological path to regulate the Internet information can be attributed to China's national configuration, including its political system, cultural tradition, status quo of the Internet development, and the pervasive cybersecurity challenges facing its society. It is thus argued that the governance of Internet information, characteristic of spatiality, can merely be construed within specific socio-political and cultural contexts. Albeit the spatiality of the governance of the Internet information, China's approach can serve as a model for other nations to develop their own governance discourses pertaining to the Internet information. This study aims not only to unpack the Chinese discourse of the ecological governance of Internet information but also to provide useful insights into the discourse and practices of global cyber governance.
Argumentation and Persuasion in Classical Chinese Literature

Lisa Indraccolo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-70817-7_2

2021-01-01

Abstract:This article analyses the two main rhetorical techniques of “argumentation” (biàn) and “persuasion” (shuì) employed in politico-philosophical debates recorded in early Chinese argumentative texts of the Warring States period (ca. 5th–3rd cent. B.C.). Through the analysis of pertinent case studies drawn from the received literature, the contribution explores the formal, structural, and grammatical features of these techniques, with attention paid to the wide selection of rhetorical and literary devices they make use of. It also further provides an overview of the historical and socio-cultural background against which such techniques developed among so called “wandering persuaders” (yóushuì), who were travelling from court to court to offer their services as political advisors and diplomats to the local rulers of the time.
Persuasion or Insulting? Unpacking Discursive Strategies of Gender Debate in Everyday Feminism in China

Yue Deng,Zheng Chen,Changyang He,Zhicong Lu,Bo Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3613904.3642194

2024-03-24

Abstract:Speaking out for women's daily needs on social media has become a crucial form of everyday feminism in China. Gender debate naturally intertwines with such feminist advocacy, where users in opposite stances discuss gender-related issues through intense discourse. The complexities of gender debate necessitate a systematic understanding of discursive strategies for achieving effective gender communication that balances civility and constructiveness. To address this problem, we adopted a mixed-methods study to navigate discursive strategies in gender debate, focusing on 38,636 posts and 187,539 comments from two representative cases in China. Through open coding, we identified a comprehensive taxonomy of linguistic strategies in gender debate, capturing five overarching themes including derogation, gender distinction, intensification, mitigation, and cognizance guidance. Further, we applied regression analysis to unveil these strategies' correlations with user participation and response, illustrating the tension between debating tactics and public engagement. We discuss design implications to facilitate feminist advocacy on social media.

Human-Computer Interaction
Shared Discourse Construction in the International Communication of Contemporary Chinese Values

Wenyan Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.37420/j.cer.2024.032

2024-04-14

Abstract:In contemporary China, the international communication discourse system has an important role that cannot be ignored, which is not only the core element of competition between countries, but also the key to building a new international order. In order to enhance the effect of international communication, China must start from the content of discourse, continuously improve the quality of discourse, and build a comprehensive and systematic discourse system. In the context of globalization, respecting the interests of nations and countries while actively advocating the concept of new globalism in pursuit of the common interests of mankind has a far-reaching impact on the development of international communication discourse. This article adopts the strategy of “balanced communication” to enhance the credibility of China’s foreign discourse and the persuasive power of its value-oriented approach through objective and comprehensive reporting, so as to enhance the shared nature of China’s discourse and international recognition.

Political Science
On China's Discourse Ability

Chen Rudong

2011-01-01

Abstract:With the globalization and the development and extension of new media technology,national discourse and its ability have become not only an important issue of the practice of national communication,but also an important subject in the studies of discourse,rhetoric,journalism and communication.In an era of world-order restructuring,it is worthwhile to study how national leaders and governmental officials of China can put forward appealing,influential and creative ideas about international and domestic major issues by way of discourse,how national media can improve the quality and efficiency of national communication,how citizens can shape their fine images of a great cultural nation,and how China's national strength and national rhetoric ability can be enhanced.This article tries to briefly expound the nature,connotation,composition,forms,current situation,problems and strategies of China's national discourse and its ability,as well as the corresponding national communication and national rhetoric from multi-disciplinary perspectives,in the hope of benefiting the enhancement of the influence of China's national discourse in the era of globalization and world-order restructuring,the shaping of a new national image,the enhancement of China's soft power,and the development of the studies on discourse and rhetoric and their application.
A Semantic Analysis of the Notion of Consultative Democracy: Xieshang Minzhu (协商民主) in the Chinese Official Political Discourses

Rongxin Li,Xiaofang Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/jnmlp-2020-0004

2020-06-17

Abstract:Abstract Chinese politics are characterized by the complex issues of a large population and centralized political powers, which offers a distinct political model from the Western models. However, the last two decades have witnessed a sharp collision between Chinese and Western political thinking. In response, domestic authors have increasingly focused on the indigenization (bentuhua 本土化) of Chinese political theories and, therefore, defend the concept of politics with Chinese characteristics. In this article, the authors focus on the discourse of “deliberative democracy” within the Chinese language, namely, Xieshang minzhu 协商民主. In the current literature, almost no scholarly discussions have explored the semantics of the notion of Xieshang minzhu within Chinese politics. This article engages with this issue, both as a subject and a methodology, to better understand the political language that has been used in the official discourses in China Official propaganda mainly includes five of China’s most authoritative official media (newspapers): People’s Daily (Renmin ribao 人民日报), Guangming Daily (Guangming ribao 光明日报), Xinhua Daily(Xinhua ribao 新华日报), China Comment (Banyutan 半月谈), Qiushi (Qiushi 求是, formerly known as Red Flag (Hongqi 红旗)), Xi Jinping’s series of important speech databases and official documents on the subject of Xieshang or Xieshang minzhu in the Party-Building Database. by 1) establishing a textual corpus by collecting relevant data into the Chinese and English groups through keywords; 2) conducting a statistical analysis based on the Word Cloud and Diagram analyses; and 3) using Word2Vec to calculate the relationship among other sub-keywords. The purpose of this contribution is to differentiate Xieshang minzhu as adopted by Chinese official discourses embedded in the logic of political reforms from the Western discourses. The semantic analysis presented here also serves as a methodology that systematically develops a conceptual model of xieshang , which further clarifies the misconceptions and errors in the existing literature. The authors also provide an outline of the polysemic notion of deliberative democracy, which not only exists within an authoritarian regime but is also present in other forms and other languages (such as Chinese). This serves to further maintain the legitimacy of the “socialist democracy with Chinese characteristics .”
Discourse construction of social power: interpersonal rhetoric in editorials of the China Daily

Liu Lihua

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1461445608098498

IF: 1.8

2009-02-01

Discourse Studies

Abstract:Based on systemic functional linguistics, and especially newly developed appraisal theory, this study uses editorials from the China Daily to investigate patterns of interpersonal rhetoric devised to construct and shape public opinion. Attitudinal lexis and modal expressions are examined separately with the object of discovering how editorials communicate their evaluation of their subject matter. This article contends that the author of an editorial is more likely to be explicit in evaluating events and implicit in evaluating behaviour and that he/she seldom attributes attitudes to other sources. Modality occurs frequently in editorial discourse. Modal expressions of certainty, necessity and obligation (as realized by will, should, need to, have to, must) are particularly common and indicate the authority and power nature of the discourse. Modal expressions of obligation/necessity normally occur at the end of the text in order to make the most powerful possible appeal to the reader.

communication
Rhetorical Features of Public Affairs Discussion on Online Forums and the Causes

Xuelian JIN,Jinsheng TENG,Deshan YANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1673-8268.2014.05.023

2014-01-01

Abstract:Recently,public affairs discussion has flourished in China.However,studies of its rhetorical features are scarce.Through reviewing existing literature on rhetorical features of cyber language and analysing sampled texts,the pa-per designs instruments to analyse the rhetorical features of online public affairs discussion language and explores the cau-ses.It has been found that online public affairs discussion language displays rhetorical features different from the common cyber language.It hardly uses any non-language signs for the purpose of fun or convenience;it tends to use mainly the written language;and its style is serious,severe and critical.At the same time,it shows low level of rationality.The u-nique rhetorical features reflect the intensification and exposure of social contradictions during the transitional period,the profound influence of long-time authoritarian political culture,the thriving of public sphere and public’s growing aware-ness and ability of public participation.
Discursive Strategy of Opinion Expression and Government Response in China: Text Analysis Based on Online Petitions

Feng Li,Yang Liu,Tianguang Meng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tele.2019.06.001

IF: 9.14

2019-01-01

Telematics and Informatics

Abstract:In the Internet era, citizens' opinion expression through online petition platforms provides us a new opportunity to explore the interaction between citizens' interest articulation and government response. Using a huge amount of text data from a Chinese online petition forum started in 2008, we explored the citizens' discursive strategies to express their demands and examined the effect of political discourses on government response. From the perspective of self-identity, we identified three separate discourses: individualism, relational collectivism, and group collectivism. In general, nowadays Chinese citizens prefer the discourse of relational collectivism, and the governments are more likely to respond to demands reflecting relational collectivism. We also distinguished the way of opinions expression with paternalistic discourse and legalistic discourse. Although more citizens justify their demands with legalistic discourse, the governments are more likely to respond to expressions reflecting paternalism. We found that Chinese citizens strategically express their demands by employing different political discourses, such as the discourses of relational collectivism and paternalism, whereas the government's selective response implies that the discursive strategy may fulfill citizens' interest to some extent.
Outline of Chinese Journalism Theoretical Discourse System: Concepts, Domains and Expressions

Hu Yu,Yu Xin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.16602/j.gmj.20180001

2018-01-01

Abstract:To form a theoretical discourse system which could both reflect the Chinese reality and be applied to other contexts worldwide, has become the significant demand for the construction of Chinese journalism. With perspectives on the conclusions of constructive principles, discourse structures and literature reviews, this article analyzed the principal topics from three levels containing concepts, domains and expressions, while several cases were analyzed to illustrate the key points.
Political Discourse in Chinese Urban Community: Pragmatic Utility and Ideological Fatigue

Yang Zheng,Jieren Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10670564.2022.2124355

IF: 3.126

2023-01-01

Journal of Contemporary China

Abstract:China's urban community is an important venue to examine the function of political discourse. Drawing on the theory of strategic action field, this article regards community as a field where officials act as incumbents, citizens as challengers, and the political discourse as an internal governance unit. The empirical data from multiple cities demonstrates that political discourses have facilitated the incumbents with several pragmatic utilities such as assuring the state's dominance, mobilizing citizens' participation, and disciplining residents' regular behaviors. Meanwhile, these discourses have met the problem of ideological fatigue. Local officials' hypocritical identification and citizens' disguised conformity disenable the Party-state to win recognition from both citizens and officials. The findings of this article enrich the current study of political discourse with a new perspective.
The marketization of public discourse: The Chinese universities

Zhengrui Han

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1750481313503221

2013-10-22

Abstract:Contemporary universities are characteristic of an evident proliferation of corporate discourse. A sole concentration on the production of new knowledge and the education of students does not ensure the prosperity or even survival of universities any longer, and equally important are the admission of elite students, the outcome-based evaluation of academic performance, the establishment of alumni network and also fundraising. This article examines how and to what extent this trend of marketization has invaded the order of discourse of Chinese universities. The research methodology combines the paradigms of critical discourse analysis (CDA) and the tenets of critical genre analysis [Bhatia VK (2007) Towards critical genre analysis. In: Bhatia VK, Flowerdew J and Jones RH (eds) Advances in Discourse Studies. London: Routledge, pp. 166–177], with particular attention paid to the notion of genre, interdiscursivity and conversationalization. The texts examined include ceremonial speeches, regulatory documents, insiders’ accounts and field notes. Analytical results show that the trend of marketization, in spite of a potential threat for academic integrity, does facilitate the institutional restructuring and transformation of universities in the context of Mainland China.

communication
Rhetorical Study of Scholarly Discourse on China's National Defense

X. Shi

Abstract:With the rise of China and America's‘Asia-pivot'over the recent years, China's national security is receiving increasing international attention. The present research, as part of‘contemporary Chinese national defense discourse studies', focuses on the rhetoric of international academic publications and aims(a) to examine the ways key concepts, standpoints, and arguments are constructed and(b) to assess the cultural meanings of such rhetorical renderings. By looking at an article published in 2013 by an Australian scholar as well as its wider context, the paper shows that the ideas of‘China threat',‘China's defense discourse is untrustworthy'and‘China is a potential enemy to the American security order'etc. rest on the rhetoric of binary thinking, the supremacy-of-Americansecurity and power-as-hegemony. In conclusion, the paper raises questions that Chinese national defense discourse studies needs to address.

Sociology,Political Science
Lost and Found in Transnation: Modern Conceptualization of Chinese Rhetoric

Hui Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/07350190902740026

2009-03-16

Rhetoric Review

Abstract:Why do the Chinese relate rhetoric only to stylistic devices in writing? This question, which has puzzled scholars for decades, is finally answered. Modern Chinese rhetoric began to form in the late 1800s when Chinese students learned Western rhetoric from their Japanese professors, who translated it into “the study of beautiful prose,” subsequently severing it from oratory. In the early twentieth century, scholars returning from Japan and the US integrated Japanese theories and Anglo-American figures of speech into Chinese literary and literacy traditions despite nativists' protests and appropriated them into a canon of aesthetics only for writing studies.
Popular Understanding of Democracy in Contemporary China

Peng Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13510347.2018.1482534

2018-01-01

Democratization

Abstract:By taking the official state ideology into consideration, this article seeks to contribute to the study of public opinion of democracy under non-democratic regimes by analysing both qualitative and quantitative evidence collected in China. An examination of the ruling Chinese Communist Party (CCP)'s discourse on democracy reveals that the CCP endorses popular sovereignty and political participation while denying political contestation. Meanwhile, the concept of democracy can have three distinctive meanings among ordinary Chinese: democracy as freedom, democracy as political participation to ensure government accountability, and democracy as good socio-economic performance. Survey data show that the majority of informed Chinese respondents treat democracy as political participation to ensure government accountability, which indicates that Chinese understanding of democracy has reached to a certain degree of consensus that is closer to universally-shared idea of democracy rather than being culturally distinctive.
A war or merely friction? Examining news reports on the current Sino-U.S. trade dispute in The New York Times and China Daily

Fu Chen,Guofeng Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17405904.2020.1844252

IF: 1.642

2020-11-23

Critical Discourse Studies

Abstract:The ongoing Sino-U.S. trade dispute between the world's two largest economies has since 2018 attracted much attention from the international media. This study used the approach of corpus-assisted discourse studies to compare how leading English-language newspapers from each side—The New York Times (NYT) and China Daily (CD) — discursively constructed this issue. The findings indicated that while NYT tended to profile the trade conflict as a 'war' in line with mainstream hard-line ideologies that emphasize China's presumed threat to national security of the U.S., CD sought to dial down the rhetoric and showed a preference for defining the matter as a 'friction', consistent with the tenet of 'pragmatic nationalism' endorsed by the Communist Party of China. Accordingly, the two newspapers framed the causes, moral evaluation/consequences, and treatment of the issue in congruence with their respective dominant metaphors by means of various linguistic patterns. These differences are interpreted with regard to each side's underlying ideologies and national interests.

communication
A Review of the Research on Discourse System with Chinese Characteristics Based on the Content Analysis Method

Yan Chu,Peiqi Sun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.36348/sijll.2022.v05i02.004

2022-02-26

Scholars International Journal of Linguistics and Literature

Abstract:Nowadays, the construction of discourse system with Chinese characteristics is an important part of the comprehensive promotion of Chinese Characteristic Major-country Diplomacy. It is also an important way to shape a true, three-dimensional and comprehensive image of China and to coordinate the domestic and international situations. As our country pays more and more attention to building a national discourse system, discourse system with Chinese characteristics has gradually become a topic of eager attention by the majority of scholars. Using the content analysis method, this article analyzes the number, quality, hot spots, discipline distribution, author distribution and fund distribution of articles on discourse system with Chinese characteristics published in Peking University core journals and CSSCI journals of CNKI from 2011 to 2021, in order to reflect the research status and development trend of discourse system with Chinese characteristics in recent ten years, and to provide a reference for the study of discourse system with Chinese characteristics in the future. The results show that: (1) The research on discourse system with Chinese characteristics is highly valued by our country and scholars from all walks of life, and the research prospect is considerable. (2) The current research hotspots are mainly concentrated on the discourse system, socialism with Chinese characteristics, philosophy and social sciences with Chinese characteristics, and academic discourse systems, etc. (3) The discipline distribution of the research on discourse system with Chinese characteristics is mainly concentrated in multi-disciplinary fields such as Chinese politics and international politics, social science theories and methods, higher education, news and media, showing the potential of extensive integration of discourse system with Chinese characteristics research with other disciplines. (4) The country attaches great importance to the research on discourse system with Chinese characteristics, but the local support is insufficient. (5) The amount of research on discourse system with Chinese characteristics is considerable, but the quality is not good enough. The depth and breadth of the research on discourse system with Chinese characteristics need to be further expanded.
Political Argumentation by Reciting Poems in the Spring and Autumn Period of Ancient China

Shi-er Ju,Zhi-xi Chen,Yang He

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10503-020-09527-x

2020-06-25

Argumentation

Abstract:This paper introduces the Generalized Argumentation Theory which takes argumentation as a locally rational socio-cultural interaction governed by social norms and carried out through discourse between the members of a socio-cultural community in order to reason things out. Then we bring in the basic structure of generalized argumentation and the localized procedure of Generalized Argumentation Theory for studying the argumentative rules (social norms). On the basis of above introduction, we use the localized procedure to analyze a case of political argumentation by reciting poems in ancient China. By doing so, it's indicated that political argumentation by reciting poems, in essence, takes cultural principle of <i>Li</i> of the Spring and Autumn Period as argumentative rules and uses poems to express ideas, in virtue of which arguments are accepted as locally rational by the politicians at that time. At last, the <i>Little Red Book</i> quotation fight, a similar political activity, is discussed briefly to show the significance that ancient Chinese political argumentation has on contemporary argumentation.

communication,linguistics

Argumentative Discourse in Contemporary China

Cultural Discourse Studies: Researching Chinese Theory, Methods and Topics (2nd Edition) Cultural Discourse Studies: Researching Chinese Theory, Methods and Topics (2nd Edition), by Shi-Xu, Peking University Press, 2022, US$10.86, 330 Pp.

On The Contemporary Construction Of The Chinese System Of Academic Discourse

Exploring the Cyber Governance Discourse: A Perspective from China

Argumentation and Persuasion in Classical Chinese Literature

Persuasion or Insulting? Unpacking Discursive Strategies of Gender Debate in Everyday Feminism in China

Shared Discourse Construction in the International Communication of Contemporary Chinese Values

On China's Discourse Ability

A Semantic Analysis of the Notion of Consultative Democracy: Xieshang Minzhu (协商民主) in the Chinese Official Political Discourses

Discourse construction of social power: interpersonal rhetoric in editorials of the China Daily

Rhetorical Features of Public Affairs Discussion on Online Forums and the Causes

Discursive Strategy of Opinion Expression and Government Response in China: Text Analysis Based on Online Petitions

Outline of Chinese Journalism Theoretical Discourse System: Concepts, Domains and Expressions

Political Discourse in Chinese Urban Community: Pragmatic Utility and Ideological Fatigue

The marketization of public discourse: The Chinese universities

Rhetorical Study of Scholarly Discourse on China's National Defense

Lost and Found in Transnation: Modern Conceptualization of Chinese Rhetoric

Popular Understanding of Democracy in Contemporary China

A war or merely friction? Examining news reports on the current Sino-U.S. trade dispute in The New York Times and China Daily

A Review of the Research on Discourse System with Chinese Characteristics Based on the Content Analysis Method

Political Argumentation by Reciting Poems in the Spring and Autumn Period of Ancient China