State Capitalism and the Chinese Economic Miracle
Kellee S. Tsai,Barry Naughton
2015-01-01
Abstract:A driver circling central Beijing on the Second or Third Ring Roads today passes scores of shiny modern towers, twenty or thirty stories high. The earliest of these towers, built in the 1980s and 1990s, were international hotels and foreign company offices. Since 2000, however, the bulk of the prestige projects and glass towers on the inner ring roads have been built by Chinese stateowned corporations. They stand like the ramparts of a mighty modern fortress where the ancient city walls once stood. To the east, they are mainly industrial companies, and to the west, predominantly financial. On the east side, when the sun is going down, you can see through the multistory glass atrium connecting the two halves of the China National Petroleum Corporation building, and see employees in the upper floor basketball court, seemingly playing in mid-air. For sheer display, though, nothing can match the towers of China Central Television, which bring a note of brutal elegance to the city. These buildings testify to the continuing, indeed increased, importance of state-owned enterprises in the Chinese economic model. The physical shape of Beijing increasingly exhibits the configuration of economic power in China, even as it asserts China’s economic importance and modernity. The prominence of state business in what is overwhelmingly a market economy inevitably raises questions about the nature of China’s system. Among the global spectrum of political and economic models, which are most relevant to China’s future? Is China following in the footsteps of its developmental state neighbors in East Asia? Or is the socialist rhetoric a façade for a reality more similar to the oligarchic capitalism seen in some other postsocialist countries? Or could it be that, as Chinese “New Left” intellectuals hope, a more equitable mode of government-shaped capitalism is going to be fashioned out of socialist values and institutions? To even begin to address these big questions, we need to understand much better the current configuration of government and business in China. This volume is based on the proposition that a reasonably stable and mutually reinforcing arrangement of political and economic institutions has now emerged in China, after almost fifty years of