Institutional Change and the Exile of the Once Fittest

Yan Chen,Nan Hu,Ling Liu,Yi Dong
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2016.13856abstract
2016-01-01
Abstract:Extensive research suggests that performance tends to improve with experiences, on the one hand, and that experiences may sometimes lead to maladaptation under environmental change, on the other hand. In this study, we examine how financial analysts learn from experiences and how an institutional change affects learning and adaptation. We find that the value of experiences is situated in the context of the prevailing institutional logic. When the prevailing institutional logic shifts, experiences in an old institutional regime may negatively affect performance in a new institutional regime. We also find that, when employees suffer from negative experience transfer, they may risk being let go by their employers and also being completely exiled from their field. However, a filed may consist of multiple subfields with varying institutional logics, and the institutional logic in some subfields may be consistent with the direction of the institutional change. As a result, some subfields may allow people to accumulate experiences that may help them survive and thrive under institutional change. We draw implications for experiential learning, organizational adaptation, and institutional change.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?