On Exchange Traded Funds (Etfs)

Si Cheng,Massimo Massa,Hong Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2022854

2012-01-01

Abstract:We study the role of ETFs inside the financial conglomerates they are affiliated with. We hypothesize that, through synthetic operations, ETFs could provide a cheap source of funding for the affiliated bank to leverage up their information advantage and be used to subsidize affiliated parties in the financial conglomerate. We document three major findings based on a complete sample of international ETFs and OEFs over the period 2001–2009. First, a large proportion of the portfolio of the ETFs is not made of stocks of the benchmark that the funds track. Rather, ETFs often hold stocks that are in common with affiliated banks, other ETFs, and OEFs in excess of their benchmarks. Second, such common holdings are largely consistent with the funding and subsidizing roles of ETFs within a financial conglomerate. Lastly, the ETF market price is discounted more when the distress risk of the affiliated bank is higher, suggesting that the market interprets the overall synthetic operations of ETFs as a detriment to investors. These results have important normative implications both in terms of consumer protection and in terms of financial stability.