Abstract:Educational and Psychological Measurement, Ahead of Print. Rapid-guessing behavior in data can compromise our ability to estimate item and person parameters accurately. Consequently, it is crucial to model data with rapid-guessing patterns in a way that can produce unbiased ability estimates. This study proposes and evaluates three alternative modeling approaches that follow the logic of the effort-moderated item response theory model (EM-IRT) to analyze response data with rapid-guessing responses. One is the two-step EM-IRT model, which utilizes the item parameters estimated by respondents without rapid-guessing behavior and was initially proposed by Rios and Soland without further investigation. The other two models are effort-moderated multidimensional models (EM-MIRT), which we introduce in this study and vary as both between-item and within-item structures. The advantage of the EM-MIRT model is to account for the underlying relationship between rapid-guessing propensity and ability. The three models were compared with the traditional EM-IRT model regarding the accuracy of parameter recovery in various simulated conditions. Results demonstrated that the two-step EM-IRT and between-item EM-MIRT model consistently outperformed the traditional EM-IRT model under various conditions, with the two-step EM-IRT estimation generally delivering the best performance, especially for ability and item difficulty parameters estimation. In addition, different rapid-guessing patterns (i.e., difficulty-based, changing state, and decreasing effort) did not affect the performance of the two-step EM-IRT model. Overall, the findings suggest that the EM-IRT model with the two-step parameter estimation method can be applied in practice for estimating ability in the presence of rapid-guessing responses due to its accuracy and efficiency. The between-item EM-MIRT model can be used as an alternative model when there is no significant mean difference in the ability estimates between examinees who exhibit rapid-guessing behavior and those who do not.

Multimodal Likelihoods in Educational Assessment

Multimodal Likelihoods in Educational Assessment Will the Real Maximum Likelihood Score Please Stand Up?

Item-Weighted Likelihood Method for Measuring Growth in Longitudinal Study With Tests Composed of Both Dichotomous and Polytomous Items

Applying Unidimensional and Multidimensional Item Response Theory Models in Testlet-Based Reading Assessment

Multilevel Rasch Modeling of Two-Tier Multiple Choice Test: A Case Study Using Lawson’s Classroom Test of Scientific Reasoning

Joint Maximum Likelihood Estimation for High-dimensional Exploratory Item Response Analysis

Modeling Rapid Guessing Behaviors in Computer-Based Testlet Items

Enhancing Effort-Moderated Item Response Theory Models by Evaluating a Two-Step Estimation Method and Multidimensional Variations on the Model

Joint Maximum Likelihood Estimation for High-Dimensional Exploratory Item Factor Analysis

Flexible Bayesian modelling in dichotomous item response theory using mixtures of skewed item curves

Concurrent Use of Response Time and Response Accuracy for Detecting Examinees with Item Preknowledge

Identifying Effortful Individuals With Mixture Modeling Response Accuracy and Response Time Simultaneously to Improve Item Parameter Estimation

Robustness of Parameter Estimation to Assumptions of Normality in the Multidimensional Graded Response Model

Maximum Marginal Likelihood Estimation of a Monotonic Polynomial Generalized Partial Credit Model with Applications to Multiple Group Analysis

Applications of the Analytically Derived Asymptotic Standard Errors of Item Response Theory Item Parameter Estimates

Accelerating L1-penalized expectation maximization algorithm for latent variable selection in multidimensional two-parameter logistic models

Detecting Aberrant Behavior and Item Preknowledge: A Comparison of Mixture Modeling Method and Residual Method

Properties of Ability Estimation Methods in Computerized Adaptive Testing

Bayesian Modal Estimation for the One-Parameter Logistic Ability-Based Guessing (1PL-AG) Model

A Mixture Response Time Process Model for Aberrant Behaviors and Item Nonresponses

A Mixture Response Model for Identifying Item Preknowledge