Abstract:Generative models offer design diversity but tend to be computationally expensive, while non-generative models are computationally cost-effective but produce less diverse and often invalid designs. However, the limitations of non-generative models can be overcome with the introduction of augmented shape signature vectors (SSVs) to represent both geometric and physical information. This recent advancement has inspired a systematic comparison of the effectiveness and efficiency of generative and non-generative models in constructing design spaces for novel and efficient design exploration and shape optimization, which is demonstrated in this work. These models are showcased in airfoil/hydrofoil design, and a comparison of the resulting design spaces is conducted in this work. A conventional generative adversarial network (GAN) and a state-of-the-art generative model, the performance-augmented diverse generative adversarial network (PaDGAN), are juxtaposed with a linear non-generative model based on the coupling of the Karhunen–Loève Expansion and a physics-informed shape signature vector (SSV-KLE). The comparison demonstrates that, with an appropriate shape encoding and a physics-augmented design space, non-generative models have the potential to cost-effectively generate high-performing valid designs with enhanced coverage of the design space. In this work, both approaches were applied to two large foil profile datasets comprising real-world and artificial designs generated through either a profile-generating parametric model or a deep-learning approach. These datasets were further enriched with integral properties of their members' shapes, as well as physics-informed parameters. The obtained results illustrate that the design spaces constructed by the non-generative model outperform the generative model in terms of design validity, generating robust latent spaces with no or significantly fewer invalid designs when compared to generative models. The performance and diversity of the generated designs were compared to provide further insights about the quality of the resulting spaces. These findings can aid the engineering design community in making informed decisions when constructing design spaces for shape optimization, as it has been demonstrated that, under certain conditions, computationally inexpensive approaches can closely match or even outperform state-of-the art generative models.

Exploiting Generative Models for Performance Predictions of 3D Car Designs

Data-Driven Car Drag Prediction With Depth and Normal Renderings

VehicleSDF: A 3D generative model for constrained engineering design via surrogate modeling

Design representation for performance evaluation of 3D shapes in structure-aware generative design

Surrogate Modeling of Car Drag Coefficient with Depth and Normal Renderings

3D car shape reconstruction from a contour sketch using GAN and lazy learning

DeepMorpher: deep learning-based design space dimensionality reduction for shape optimisation

Towards Goal, Feasibility, and Diversity-Oriented Deep Generative Models in Design

A Generative Neural Network Approach for 3D Multi-Criteria Design Generation and Optimization of an Engine Mount for an Unmanned Air Vehicle

Bayesian Mesh Optimization for Graph Neural Networks to Enhance Engineering Performance Prediction

Product Aesthetic Design: A Machine Learning Augmentation

Interactive design of 2D car profiles with aerodynamic feedback

Deep Generative Models in Engineering Design: A Review

Generative AI-based Prompt Evolution Engineering Design Optimization With Vision-Language Model

3D Design Using Generative Adversarial Networks and Physics-Based Validation

Generative vs. Non-Generative Models in Engineering Shape Optimization

GINA-3D: Learning to Generate Implicit Neural Assets in the Wild

A Review of Generative Models for 3D Vehicle Wheel Generation and Synthesis

Integrating deep learning into CAD/CAE system: generative design and evaluation of 3D conceptual wheel

Representing engineering design changes in finite element models using directed point cloud autoencoders

A Deep Learning-Based CAE Approach for Simulating 3D Vehicle Wheels Under Real-World Conditions