Abstract:A field study was performed to examine the effects of correlated color temperature (CCT) and lumen output of fluorescent lighting on office occupants' visual comfort, brightness perception, satisfaction, and self-reported productivity. Twenty-six participants were recruited (mean age = 38.8 years; age range = 23–55 years). Ten of them had daylight access in their personal work areas. Four lamp types were selected to create luminous conditions organized as a 2 × 2 factorial design, comprising two levels of CCT (i.e., 3500 and 5000 K) and lumen output (i.e., 2330 and ≈3000 lm). Each condition lasted two weeks. Under each condition, participants adapted during the first week. During the second week they completed ecological momentary assessments (EMAs) three times daily using smart phones. Two of the daily EMAs included questions about lighting. Participants also completed a web-based survey on the last day of each condition. The results from the EMA (60.0% response rate) and web-based (77.2% response rate) surveys were generally consistent, indicating that CCT significantly affected spatial brightness perception, visual comfort, satisfaction, and self-reported productivity. The luminous conditions at 5000 K (visually cooler) were rated to be brighter than those at 3500 K (visually warmer), especially when higher lumen output was in place. However, the increase in spatial brightness perception came with lower satisfaction, worse visual comfort, and worse self-reported productivity. The conditions at 5000 K were judged to be too cool, especially for those who had daylight in their work areas. The results of this study do not support the spectrally enhanced lighting (SEL) method advocated by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) as an energy savings strategy. Even when higher CCT resulted in higher spatial brightness perception, occupants' visual comfort and satisfaction were compromised.

Human perception and preferences of evening office lighting in terms of the LED spectrum

The Impact of LED on Human Visual Experience

Effects of Illumination and Color Temperature Distribution on Subjective Perception

Influence of the Spectrum of All-Day LED Lighting on Human Daytime and Nighttime Performance

Atmosphere Perception of LED Dynamic Lighting with Color Varied in Cool and Warm Hue

Colourising Daylight in Buildings: Visual Responses in a Daylit Room Supplemented with Colour-Changing Light-Emitting Diode Luminaires

The effect of LED lighting on color discrimination and preference of elderly people

Influence of Color Temperature on Comfort and Preference for LED Indoor Lighting

A Study of Atmosphere Perception of Dynamic Coloured Light

Investigation on Circadian Regulation of Four-Primary LED Display Differed in People by GA

Effects of LED Lighting on Office Work Performance

A Field Study of Individual, Energy-Efficient, and Human-Centered Indoor Electric Lighting: Its Impact on Comfort and Visual Performance in an Open-Plan Office Part 1

The Effect of Correlated Color Temperature and Illumination Level of LED Lighting on Visual Comfort during Sustained Attention Activities

Assessing the Proportions and CCT of Direct/Indirect Lighting in a Real Lit Office

Intercultural observer preference for perceived illumination chromaticity for different coloured object scenes

INFLUENCE OF LED COLOR TEMPERATURE ON LUMINANCE OF THE INTERIOR TUNNEL ZONE

Field study of office worker responses to fluorescent lighting of different CCT and lumen output

LED Light with Enhanced Color Saturation and Improved White Light Perception.

Considerations in LED Spectral Design for Enhanced Color Quality

A Proposed Lighting-Design Space: Circadian Effect Versus Visual Illuminance

The Impact of LED Lighting on People's Work Performance Between Different Age Groups