In silico methods for immunogenicity risk assessment and human homology screening for therapeutic antibodies

Aimee E. Mattei,Andres H. Gutierrez,Soorya Seshadri,Jacob Tivin,Matt Ardito,Amy S. Rosenberg,William D. Martin,Anne S. De Groot
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/19420862.2024.2333729
2024-03-28
mAbs
Abstract:In silico immunogenicity risk assessment has been an important step in the development path for many biologic therapeutics, including monoclonal antibodies. Even if the source of a given biologic is 'fully human', T cell epitopes that are contained in the sequences of the biologic may activate the immune system, enabling the development of anti-drug antibodies that can reduce drug efficacy and may contribute to adverse events. Computational tools that identify T cell epitopes from primary amino acid sequences have been used to assess the immunogenic potential of therapeutic candidates for several decades. To facilitate larger scale analyses and accelerate preclinical immunogenicity risk assessment, our group developed an integrated web-based platform called ISPRI, (Immunogenicity Screening and Protein Re-engineering Interface) that provides hands-on access through a secure web-based interface for scientists working in large and mid-sized biotech companies in the US, Europe, and Japan. This toolkit has evolved and now contains an array of algorithms that can be used individually and/or consecutively for immunogenicity assessment and protein engineering. Most analyses start with the advanced epitope mapping tool (EpiMatrix), then proceed to identify epitope clusters using ClustiMer, and then use a tool called JanusMatrix to define whether any of the T cell epitope clusters may generate a regulatory T cell response which may diminish or eliminate anti-drug antibody formation. Candidates can be compared to similar products on a normalized immunogenicity scale. Should modifications to the biologic sequence be an option, a tool for moderating putative immunogenicity by editing T cell epitopes out of the sequence is available (OptiMatrix). Although this perspective discusses the in-silico immunogenicity risk assessment for monoclonal antibodies, bi-specifics, multi-specifics, and antibody-drug conjugates, the analysis of additional therapeutic modalities such as enzyme replacement proteins, blood factor proteins, CAR-T, gene therapy products, and peptide drugs is also made available on the ISPRI platform. ISPRI (Interactive Screening and Protein Reengineering Interface) : Integrated, cloud-based, comprehensive toolkit for Immunogenicity Risk Assessment. EpiMatrix Immunogenicity Score : Combined T effector and Treg Epitope Content per unit protein. Tregitopes : Treg Epitopes found in IgG Framework that have been shown to modulate antigen-specific effector T cell responses. ClustiMer : Tool for identifying epitope rich polypeptides from within a given protein sequence. JanusMatrix : Tool for Predicting Tolerance, Putative Treg Epitopes, and Anti-self-immune responses. OptiMatrix : Tool for modifying T cell epitope sequences to reduce (or enhance) MHC binding.
medicine, research & experimental
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper mainly explores how to evaluate the **immunogenicity risk** of therapeutic antibodies through **in silico methods** and screen the potential impact of their homology with humans. Specifically, the research aims to: 1. **Identify potential T - cell epitopes**: Use computational tools to identify T - cell epitopes from the primary amino acid sequence of proteins that may trigger an immune response. These epitopes may activate T - cells, leading to the production of anti - drug antibodies (ADA), thereby reducing drug efficacy and potentially causing adverse events. 2. **Evaluate immunogenicity risk**: Develop and apply a series of computational tools to evaluate the immunogenicity risk of therapeutic antibodies. These tools can not only predict potential T - cell epitopes but also assess whether these epitopes may trigger regulatory T - cell (Treg cell) responses, thereby reducing or eliminating the formation of anti - drug antibodies. 3. **Optimize protein engineering**: Provide tools and techniques to reduce (or enhance) MHC binding by editing T - cell epitopes, thereby reducing the immunogenicity risk of biological agents. This includes modifying the sequence of biological agents to remove potential immunogenic epitopes. 4. **Large - scale analysis and accelerate pre - clinical evaluation**: Develop an integrated Web platform, ISPRI (Immunogenicity Screening and Protein Re - engineering Interface), for large - scale analysis and accelerating pre - clinical immunogenicity risk assessment of therapeutic antibodies. This platform provides scientists with the ability to access and operate these tools through a secure Web interface. ### Key technologies and tools - **EpiMatrix**: An epitope prediction tool based on the position - specific scoring matrix (PSSM), used to evaluate the binding potential of 9 - mer fragments in the input sequence with common HLA - DR supertype alleles. - **ClustiMer**: An algorithm for identifying high - density T - cell epitope clusters, which may be key areas for immune responses. - **JanusMatrix**: Used to evaluate the homology between T - cell epitopes and the human proteome and identify epitopes that may trigger tolerance responses. - **OptiMatrix**: Used to optimize protein sequences by editing T - cell epitopes to reduce their immunogenicity. ### Application scope These tools can be applied not only to monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) but also extended to the immunogenicity risk assessment of other treatment modalities such as bispecific antibodies, multispecific antibodies, antibody - drug conjugates (ADCs), enzyme - replacement proteins, blood - factor proteins, CAR - T cell therapies, gene - therapy products, and peptide drugs. Through these methods, researchers hope to identify and reduce the immunogenicity risk of therapeutic biological agents earlier, thereby improving the safety and effectiveness of drugs.