Abstract:Current studies comparing the safety and effectiveness of techniques to manage impacted fetal head during cesarean birth demonstrate multiple weaknesses. Given the limited evidence for superiority of any one technique, high quality training is needed across the range of techniques. Introduction Despite increasing incidence of impacted fetal head at cesarean birth and associated injury, it is unclear which techniques are most effective for prevention and management. A high quality evidence review in accordance with international reporting standards is currently lacking. To address this gap, we aimed to identify, assess, and synthesize studies comparing techniques to prevent or manage impacted fetal head at cesarean birth prior to or at full cervical dilatation. Material and Methods We searched MEDLINE, Emcare, Embase and Cochrane databases up to 1 January 2023 (PROSPERO: CRD420212750016). Included were randomized controlled trials (any size) and non‐randomized comparative studies (n ≥ 30 in each arm) comparing techniques or adjunctive measures to prevent or manage impacted fetal head at cesarean birth. Following screening and data extraction, we assessed risk of bias for individual studies using RoB2 and ROBINS‐I, and certainty of evidence using GRADE. We synthesized data using meta‐analysis where appropriate, including sensitivity analyses excluding data published in potential predatory journals or at risk of retraction. Results We identified 24 eligible studies (11 randomized and 13 non‐randomized) including 3558 women, that compared vaginal disimpaction, reverse breech extraction, the Patwardhan method and/or the Fetal Pillow®. GRADE certainty of evidence was low or very low for all 96 outcomes across seven reported comparisons. Pooled analysis mostly showed no or equivocal differences in outcomes across comparisons of techniques. Although some maternal outcomes suggested differences between techniques (e.g., risk ratio of 3.41 [95% CI: 2.50–4.66] for uterine incision extension with vaginal disimpaction vs. reverse breech extraction), these were based on unreliable pooled estimates given very low GRADE certainty and, in some cases, additional risk of bias introduced by data published in potential predatory journals or at risk of retraction. Conclusions The current weaknesses in the evidence base mean that no firm recommendations can be made about the superiority of any one impacted fetal head technique over another, indicating that high quality training is needed across the range of techniques. Future studies to improve the evidence base are urgently required, using a standard definition of impacted fetal head, agreed maternal and neonatal outcome sets for impacted fetal head, and internationally recommended reporting standards.

Variations of cervical head entrapment in vaginal breech births: New insights on how to prevent, manage and resolve

Management of impacted fetal head at cesarean delivery

Management of impacted fetal head at cesarean birth: A systematic review and meta‐analysis

Definition, Management, and Training in Impacted Fetal Head at Cesarean Birth: A National Survey of Maternity Professionals

Anaesthetic considerations for impacted fetal head at caesarean delivery: a focused review

Correlative analysis of different treatments of persistent occipitotransverse position on the outcome for mother and infant

Babies in occiput posterior position are significantly more likely to require an emergency cesarean birth compared with babies in occiput transverse position in the second stage of labor: A prospective observational study

Clinical Analysis of 414 Cases of Umbilical Cord Entanglement

Transcervical side by side Foley balloons for preterm breech birth: A new concept to enhance safety

The association among fetal head position, fetal head rotation and descent during the progress of labor: a clinical study of an ultrasound-based longitudinal cohort study in nulliparous women

Impacted fetal head at cesarean delivery

An unusual case of severe asphyxia with the fetal position unexpectedly inverted in a malformed uterus: a case report

The Effects of Spinning Babies® on the Nulliparous, Term, Singleton, Vertex Cesarean Rates

Digital and Manual Rotation of the Persistent Occiput Posterior Fetus

Growing Popularity of Breech Vaginal Birth

Association of Persistent Breech Presentation With External Cephalic Version Success

Difficult fetal extraction in cesarean section: Number 8 - 2024

Success Rate and Influencing Factors of External Cephalic Version for Breech Presentation

Guideline No. 439: Diagnosis and Management of Vasa Previa

Intrapartum Ultrasound Guidance to Make Safer Any Obstetric Intervention: Fetal Head Rotation, Assisted Vaginal Birth, Breech Delivery of the Second Twin

Biomechanics of pregnancy and vaginal delivery