Application of microwave ablation in the treatment of Campanacci grake Ⅲ giant cell tumor of bone of the limbs

张继孔,李振峰,程坤,李玉椿,吴玉仙,纪玉清,杨强,王光辉,李建民
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.cn101202-20200418-00133
2021-01-01
Abstract:Objective:This work aims to investigate the feasibility and clinical efficacy of microwave ablation in the treatment of Campanacci grade Ⅲ giant cell tumor of bone (GCTB) of the limbs.Methods:Retrospective analysis was conducted from July 2009 to April 2017. A total of 25 patients with GCTB of Campanacci Ⅲ in the limbs were treated by operation and were divided into the microwave curettage (12 cases) and en bloc resection (13 cases) groups. The microwave curettage group comprised seven males and five females, aged 34-69 (40.6±10.8) years; the locations of the disease were as follows: one in the distal radius, two in the proximal femur, six in the distal femur, one in the proximal tibia, and two in the proximal fibula. The en bloc resection group consisted of seven males and six females, aged 29-68(46.0±10.5) years; the locations of the disease were as follows: two cases in the distal radius, one case in the proximal humerus, two cases in the proximal femur, five cases in the distal femur, one case in the proximal tibia, one case in the distal ulna, and one case in the proximal fibula. The operation time, bleeding volume, recurrence rate, visual analog score, Musculoskeletal Tumor Society(MSTS) functional score, and complications of the two groups were compared.Results:All operations were successfully performed, and no significant vascular and nerve injury were noted during the operation. The operation time of the microwave curettage group took 103-160(121±20) min, which was significantly different from that of the en bloc resection group (119-169[147±19] min, t= 3.266, P<0.01). A significant difference was found in the amount of bleeding between the microwave curettage group (70-110(85±16)mL) and the en bloc resection group (105-225[176±36] mL, t= 8.158, P<0.01). Both groups were followed up for 24-72 months (average 31.17 months). The mean VAS score of the microwave curettage group was 1-3 (2.25±0.62) at 3 months post operation, which was more statistically significant ( t=4.588, P<0.01) than that of the en bloc resection group 3-4 (3.23±0.44); moreover, the mean MSTS score of the microwave curettage group was 27-30(28.33±0.98) at 1 year post operation, which was more statistically significant ( t= 5.566, P<0.01) than that of the en bloc resection group (25-28[26.08±1.03]). No cases of vascular or nerve burns and pathological fractures were noted after microwave ablation. One patient in the en bloc resection group suffered from the loosening of prosthesis 26 months after surgery and then underwent revision surgery. Conclusions:Microwave ablation combined with curettage can obtain fewer complications and better limb function in Campanacci Ⅲ GCTB in the limbs; nevertheless, it can obtain a similar recurrence rate with the resection group.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?