Abstract:In China, the five-year program of undergraduate education for stomatology consists of four years of lecture courses and one year of internship focused on clinical training. Dental schools provide this clinical training either in their own clinics (referred to as the one-stage pattern because all forms of practice are completed together) or by placing students in external clinics usually at non-affiliated hospitals (referred to as the three-stage program because the three primary areas are taught separately). The aims of this study were to investigate differences in teaching effect between the one-stage and the three-stage patterns and to evaluate advantages and disadvantages of the two patterns. A three-section, 31-item questionnaire was designed to assess basic and clinic information about the interns' training and their self-confidence in performing clinical procedures. The survey was administered to graduates who finished the fifth-year internship in 2012-14. Of the 356 individuals invited to participate, 303 graduates who spent their intern years in 43 academic dental institutions returned completed surveys (response rate of 85%). The one-stage group (n=121) reported longer independent operation time than the three-stage group (n=182) (p<0.01). No significant difference was found between the groups for assessment of clinic infrastructure (p=0.121). The interns were most confident in oral hygiene instruction and scale and polish (overall median=5), but showed low confidence in rubber dam placement and four other procedures (overall median=2). The one-stage group rated their confidence level higher than the three-stage group on comprehensive skills such as arranging appointments and managing patients and procedures needing long treatment periods such as molar endodontics. The three-stage group showed higher confidence on more specialized procedures such as surgical extractions and suturing. This study found that both of the two intern patterns had advantages and shortcomings in clinical training in various procedures. Combining the two could be a way to improve clinical education in China.

Investigation on the diversity of practice operation of relevant specialties of undergraduates in a comprehensive dental teaching clinic

Exploration and Practice of Comprehensive Clinical Rotation Internship for Undergraduate Dental Students: A New Internship for Undergraduate Dental Students (Preprint)

Investigation of Stolmatological Clinical Practice Training in General Clinic

Comparing Integrated and Disciplinary Clinical Training Patterns for Dental Interns: Advantages, Disadvantages, and Effect on Students' Self-Confidence

Investigation of the teaching program of periodontology for the undergraduates in China

The Preliminary Application and Effect Assessment of a Comprehensive Dental Training Case-Base

A comparison of two ways of clinical practice in pediatric dentistry

An investigation of the training of eight-year stomatological students in interdisciplinary cases treatment

Study on the Practice of Pre-Clinical Education for Stomatological Students

Investigation and Analysis of Pediatric Dentists in 2020

A feedback study of fixed prosthodontical preclinical tooth preparation training in eight-year program of oral medical students

Exploration and Practice of Peking University Model to Improve the Clinical Teaching Effect of Clinical Postgraduates Majoring in Periodontology

A Study on Establishment of Examination Criteria for the Clinical Practice of Dental Students in the Department of Prosthodontics by Delphi Method

The Knowledge of General Practice and Vocational Tendency of Undergraduate Clinical Medical Students of Zhejiang University

Preliminary application of an integrated teaching method combined with TBL, CBL and PBL in the internship education of prosthodontics

[Antimalarial serology in 1987-1988 in the Highland Plateaux, the East coast and the South of Madagascar].

On Training and Evaluation of the Clinical Competence of Undergraduates Majoring in Stomatology

Role-play in Endodontic Teaching: a Case Study

[Exploration and Practice of Periodontal Specialist Training System].

Preliminary Study on Developing General Dental Clinic Training for Students in Stomatological Specialty

Qualitative Research for Influential Factors of Patients' Satisfaction and Approval to Stomatology Interns