Abstract:Importance sampling (IS) is valuable in reducing the variance of Monte Carlo sam-pling for many areas, including finance, rare event simulation, and Bayesian inference. It is natural and obvious to combine quasi-Monte Carlo (QMC) methods with IS to achieve a faster rate of con-vergence. However, a naive replacement of Monte Carlo with QMC may not work well. This paper investigates the convergence rates of randomized QMC-based IS for estimating integrals with respect to a Gaussian measure, in which the IS measure is a Gaussian or t distribution. We prove that if the target function satisfies the so-called boundary growth condition and the covariance matrix of the IS density has eigenvalues no smaller than 1, then randomized QMC with the Gaussian proposal has a root mean squared error of O(N -1+\epsilon) for arbitrarily small \epsilon > 0. Similar results with a t distribution as the proposal are also established. These sufficient conditions help to assess the effectiveness of IS in QMC. For some particular applications, we find that the Laplace IS, a very general approach to approximate the target function by a quadratic Taylor approximation around its mode, has ei-genvalues smaller than 1, making the resulting integrand less favorable for QMC. From this point of view, when using Gaussian distributions as the IS proposal, a change of measure via Laplace IS may transform a favorable integrand into an unfavorable one for QMC although the variance of Monte Carlo sampling is reduced. We also study the effect of positivization tricks on the error rate when the integrand has mixed sign. If the smooth positivization proposed by Owen and Zhou (J. Amer. Statist. Assoc., 95 (2000), pp. 135--143) is used, the rate O(N -1+\epsilon) is retained. This is not the case if taking the positive and negative parts of the integrand. We also give some examples to verify our propositions and warn against naive replacement of Monte Carlo with QMC under IS proposals. Numerical results suggest that using Laplace IS with t distributions is more robust than that with Gaussian distributions.

Estimating Confidence Intervals and Regions for Quantiles by Monte Carlo Simulation

Confidence Intervals and Regions for Quantiles Using Conditional Monte Carlo and Generalized Likelihood Ratios.

The Grid Bootstrap for Continuous Time Models

Conditional Monte Carlo Estimation of Quantile Sensitivities

Sufficient Conditions for Central Limit Theorems and Confidence Intervals for Randomized Quasi-Monte Carlo Methods

Guaranteed Conservative Fixed Width Confidence Intervals Via Monte Carlo Sampling

Monte Carlo Confidence Sets for Identified Sets

Overlapping Batch Confidence Intervals on Statistical Functionals Constructed from Time Series: Application to Quantiles, Optimization, and Estimation

On the Asymptotic Analysis of Quantile Sensitivity Estimation by Monte Carlo Simulation.

Convergence analysis of quasi-Monte Carlo sampling for quantile and expected shortfall

Simulating Confidence Intervals for Conditional Value-at-Risk via Least-Squares Metamodels

Confidence Corridors for Multivariate Generalized Quantile Regression

Density Estimation by Monte Carlo and Quasi-Monte Carlo

Sensitivity estimation of conditional value at risk using randomized quasi-Monte Carlo

ON THE ERROR RATE OF IMPORTANCE SAMPLING WITH RANDOMIZED QUASI-MONTE CARLO*

Confidence regions for high quantiles of a heavy tailed distribution

Estimating Confidence Regions for Distortion Risk Measures and Their Gradients

Estimating Quantile Sensitivity for Financial Models with Correlations and Jumps

A Monte Carlo Study of Confidence Interval Methods for Generalizability Coefficient.

Efficient risk estimation via nested multilevel quasi-Monte Carlo simulation