When Innovation Fails: A cultural perspective on firm patenting behavior in China

Danqing Wang,Zhe Li,Nianhang Xu,Hong Zhang,Yu Zhang

2019-01-01

Abstract:The recent Sino-US ZTE dispute illustrates that many Chinese firms are good at patenting but poor at inventing fundamental technologies. We argue that this puzzling observation may have a deep social-cultural root. Particularly, alcohol and its associated “ganbei” culture, the leading social norm in China’s business community, may give rise to low efficiency in innovation by distorting both government R&D subsidies and related firm incentives. Consistent with the folk intuition that alcohol-related social norm lubricates the forming of local collusion, we find that 1) the intensity of local drinking culture inherently enhances the probability of government R&D subsidy approval; 2) firms immersed in heavier drinking culture tend to file more low-quality innovations (i.e., “utility” as opposed to “inventions” in terms of patent categories) to fulfil subsidy-related responsibilities; and 3) government subsidies in high drinking area crowd out firm’s own R&D investment. Tests based on instrumental variables lend support to a causal interpretation. Our findings have important normative implications on innovation efficiency.