The military expenditure of China, 1989–98

Shaoguang Wang

2012-01-01

Abstract:It is an open secret that the official defence budget is just a part of the resources used to support the military establishment of China. Most analysts believe that China’s published budget substantially understates its total expenditure on national defence, although there is no consensus as to where its ‘hidden sources’ of military financing lie and how large its actual defence spending really is. Estimates of China’s total military expenditure vary widely, ranging from $20 billion to $140 billion.2 A major problem with any analysis of China’s military expenditure is the veil of secrecy shrouding military allocations. Of course, the difficulty of gathering statistical data of sufficient reliability in this area is not peculiar to the case of China,3 but the traditional preoccupation of Chinese leaders with secrecy makes them extremely reluctant to publish details of the country’s military expenditure even in the crudest aggregated form. Until China published its first defence White Paper in 1995, the outside world had only known a single-line entry for defence in the annual state budget.4 Neither the 1995 nor 1998 White Paper reveals much about the country’s total military expenditure.5 For instance, defence expenditure outside the official defence budget was not mentioned at all. The absence of systematic data on defence spending, however, does not mean that it is impossible to improve the accuracy of estimates. It is only necessary to look a little further to find a surprisingly large amount of material published in China on defence economics. Examples include professional newspapers, journals, books, and national and provincial statistical publications of various kinds.6 Since they are prepared for domestic audience and some of them classified as “internally circulated only,” it is reasonable to assume that those sources are relatively reliable. Although it is often necessary to search through dozens of such publications in order to find a few useful references, these sources nevertheless represent a gold mine from which some missing pieces of China’s military expenditure puzzle can be found. This appendix attempts to tap these Chinese sources in the hope of clarifying certain key issues about Chinese military expenditure and, wherever possible, using concrete