Market Sensitivity to Product Quality, Personal Information, and Business Practice Scandals

Jijian Fan,Jiayi Xu

2018-01-01

Abstract:The financial impacts of firm scandals have been widely studied in the literature. This paper exploits a unique setting that generates a large set of systematically reported scandals, allowing us to measure investors’ responses across scandal types. The “3.15 Night” show is a Chinese TV program held annually on March 15, which aims to protect consumers’ rights. Since 1991, the program has exposed more than 250 firm violations. We document the recent 10-year scandals and use an event study approach to estimate the effects across product quality, personal information, and business practice scandals. We find that the effects are the largest for defective products, but there are also strong negative responses to personal information breaches. We find little stock response to the revelation of deceptive business practices. We also make comparisons across industry sectors and find that the consumer goods sector suffers the largest impacts, followed by the services sector, while the technology sector exhibits the smallest responses. These results shed light on how the market responds to various types of scandals and whether some industries are more vulnerable to negative effects. ∗Economics Department, University of California, Santa Cruz, CA 95064; jifan@ucsc.edu, jxu55@ucsc.edu. We thank George Bulman and participants at the UCSC applied microeconomics workshop for helpful suggestions. We also thank Luka Kocic, Tianrui Xu, Nuo Xu, Jianfeng Shi, and Ji Liu for their excellent assistance. Any remaining errors are our own.