Facilitating Large-scale Collaboration Through Effective Mechanism Design: An Economic Examination of Resource Allocation in Collaboratories

John C. Lin,Yan Chen,Thomas A. Finholt,Kan Takeuchi

2006-01-01

Abstract:In many disciplines success depends on access to scarce resources, such as unique instruments. Research on computersupported cooperative work (CSCW) has contributed to the development of technologies, such as collaboratories, that broaden access to scarce scientific and engineering resources. While broader access is often applauded, little attention has been focused on the problem of equitable and efficient resource allocation in the face of increased demand created through collaboratory use. This paper, then, applies concepts from the economic discipline of mechanism design to compare different resource allocation schemes (RAD, Vickery, and knapsack) within a hypothetical collaboratory. Experimental results show that knapsack achieves a more equitable distribution of resources than RAD or Vickery, but that RAD and Vickery are both more efficient than knapsack. The findings highlight the need for systematic exploration of allocation mechanisms within collaboratories, where simple optimization (e.g., knapsack) is likely to produce a sub-optimal match of resources to needs. More generally, the findings illustrate the utility of economic approaches in understanding issues that emerge in large-scale collaborations, such as entire scientific and engineering communities, that have not typically been the subject of CSCW research.