Citizen Participation and Government Accountability: National-Scale Experimental Evidence from Pollution Appeals in China

Mark Buntaine,Michael Greenstone,Guojun He,Mengdi Liu,Shaoda Wang,Bing Zhang

2021-01-01

Abstract:Countries around the world have launched public disclosure programs to stimulate citizen participation in environmental governance, yet little is known about whether such participation is effective and if it is what makes it so. We layer a national-scale field experiment that randomly files pollution appeals to either regulators or the violating firms through public or private channels. We find that, publicly appealing to the regulator of a firm’s violation on popular social media increases both regulatory oversight and firm compliance, which reduce subsequent violations by 40% and air and water pollution emissions by 12% and 5%, respectively. In contrast, appealing to the regulator through private channels only causes a small and statistically insignificant improvement in environmental outcomes. Additionally, we randomly vary the proportion of firms subject to appeals at the prefecture-level and find that there is a positive general equilibrium impact as the control firms in high-intensity prefectures reduce violations more than control firms in low-intensity prefectures. Analysis of ambient pollution data and additional back-of-theenvelope calculations both suggest that encouraging public participation in environmental governance would lead to significant improvements in China’s aggregate environmental quality.