Abstract:Real estate is an important driver of the Chinese economy, which itself is vital for global growth. However, data limitations make it challenging to evaluate competing claims about the state of Chinese housing markets. This paper brings new data and analysis to the study of supply and demand conditions in nearly three dozen major cities. We first document the most accurate measures of land values, construction costs, and overall house prices. We then create and investigate a number of supply and demand metrics to see if price growth reasonably can be interpreted as reflecting local market fundamentals. Key results include the following:(1) Real house price growth has been high, averaging 10% per annum since 2006. However, there is substantial heterogeneity across markets, ranging from 2.8% (Jinan) to 19.8% (Beijing). House price growth is driven by rising land values, not by construction costs. Real land values have risen by 14.4% per annum on average. In Beijing, the increase has been by a remarkable 27.5% per year (or by 1036%) since 2004.(2) There is variation about the strong positive trend in house price and land value growth. Land values fell by nearly one-third at the beginning of the global financial crisis, but more than fully recovered amidst the 2009-2010 Chinese stimulus. More recent growth has been much more modest, with some markets beginning to decline. Quantities of land sales by local governments to private residential developers have dropped sharply since 2013. The most recent data show transactions volumes down by half or more. This should lead to a reduced supply of new housing units in coming years.(3) Market-level analysis of short- and longer-run changes in supply demand balances finds important variation across markets. In the major East region markets of Beijing, Hangzhou, Shanghai and Shenzhen which have experienced very high rates of real price growth, we estimate that the growth in households demanding housing units has outpaced new construction since the turn of the century. However, there are thirteen large markets, primarily in the interior of the country, in which new housing production has outpaced household growth by at least 30% and another eleven in which it did so by at least 10%. Regression results show that a one standard deviation increase in local market housing inventory is associated with a 0.45 standard deviation lower rate of real house price growth the following year.(4) There are no official data on residential vacancy rates in China, but some researchers have reported very high figures (17%+). We develop a new series at the provincial level which yields a much lower vacancy rate on average, but it has been rising from 5.2% in 2009 to 7.8% in 2014.(5) The risk of housing even in markets such as Beijing which show no evidence of oversupply, is best evidenced by price-to-rent ratios. They are well above 50 in the capital city. Poterba's (1984) user cost model suggests these levels can be justified only if owners have sufficiently high expectations of future capital gains. Even a modest one percentage point drop in expected appreciation (or increase in interest rates) would result in a drop in prices of about one-third, absent an offsetting increase in rents. (C) 2016 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

Estimating the Leverage Condition of China’s Urban Households: Evidence from the Housing Sector

Housing Price, Consumption, and Financial Market: Evidence from Urban Household Data in China

Local Government Debt and Firm Leverage: Evidence from China

Chinese Corporate Debt and Credit Misallocation*

Housing Market and Household Consumption in Urban China: A Debt Perspective

Excess Liquidity and Credit Misallocation: Evidence from China

Evaluating the Risk of Chinese Housing Markets: What We Know and What We Need to Know

Influence of Digital Finance on Household Leverage Ratio from the Perspective of Consumption Effect and Income Effect

Housing wealth and household consumption in urban China

Land Finance, Real Estate Market, and Local Government Debt Risk: Evidence from China

Macroeconomic Policy, Financial Resource Allocation and the High Leverage Ratio of Enterprises Sector

Informal Borrowing and Home Purchase: Evidence from Urban China

How does digital finance impact the leverage of Chinese households?

Understanding the Risk of China's Local Government Debts and its Linkage with Property Markets

Difference in Housing Finance Usage and Its Impact on Housing Wealth Inequality in Urban China

Accessibility of Homeownership in Urban China: An Empirical Study of Borrower Characteristics and the Housing Provident Fund

Study of the Nonlinear Effect of Debt Leverage on Household Financial Asset Allocation

Inventory,House Price Fluctuations and Enterprise Risks:Evidence from China's Listed Real Estate Developers

How Home Buyers Finance Their Homeownership in Post-Reform Urban China? Changing Dynamics of Variegated Financial Pathways

Housing wealth appreciation and consumption: evidence from China

Housing wealth appreciation and heterogeneous household consumption: Evidence from China