Microwave ablation: Results with double 915MHz antennae in ex vivo bovine Livers
Wenyuan Shi,Ping Liang,Qiang Zhu,Xiaoling Yu,Qiujie Shao,Tong Lu,Yang Wang,Baowei Dong
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejrad.2010.03.015
IF: 4.531
2011-01-01
European Journal of Radiology
Abstract:Purpose To investigate the settings for the optimal microwave ablation geometry with the simultaneous application of double 915 MHz antennae in ex vivo bovine livers, so as to provide the technical basis for treating large liver tumor in one ablation session. Materials and methods MWAs were performed on ex vivo bovine livers by simultaneously application of double 915 MHz internally cooled-shaft antennae. Four power settings (50, 60, 70 and 80 W) were used during MWAs, while application time was fixed at 10 min. Three inter-antenna distances (2.0, 2.5 and 3.0 cm) were used. Diameters and shapes of the coagulation zones were observed on gross specimens. Results (1) The coagulation shape was related to the inter-antenna distance, which was most spherical at an inter-antenna distance of 2.0 cm. A recess of the coagulation zone was observed at an inter-antenna distances of 2.5 and 3.0 cm. (2) The long-axis and short-axis coagulation diameter enlarged with increasing power output. However, there were no significant differences in the coagulation diameters between 70 and 80 W ( P > 0.05). More desirable coagulation geometry could be obtained by simultaneous application of double antennae at 70 W for 10 min with an inter-antenna distance of 2.0 cm, the long-axis and short-axis coagulation diameter were 6.95 ± 0.32 cm and 5.30 ± 0.22 cm, respectively. Conclusion Simultaneous application of double 915 MHz antennae can generate large coagulation zones with desirable shape which may be advantageous for treating large liver tumor in one ablation session. Keywords Microwave ablation 915 MHz microwave Ex vivo Liver cancer Experimental study 1 Introduction Imaging-guided thermal ablation has undergone tremendous progress due to modern technological advances. The most commonly employed techniques include radiofrequency (RF), microwave, laser, etc. Local thermal ablation has attracted widespread attention because of its minimal invasiveness, good tolerance, and relatively lower price [1–5] . Another advantage is that it can also be applied to patients who are not candidates for surgical resection. Microwave ablation (MWA) shares the common advantages of thermal ablation techniques. Compared with RF ablation, MWA heating is primarily active while RF ablation heating is primarily passive. MWA has a larger zone of active heating and far less rely on conduction of electricity into tissue. Furthermore, MWA is less affected by the heat-sink effect of local blood vessels. These characteristics may allow for more complete tumor kill both within a targeted zone and next to vessels [6] . In addition, MWA with simultaneous application of multiple antennae is not interfered seen in RF ablation, so it could produce a greater ablation effect within a short treatment time [7] . At present, two frequencies—915 and 2,450 MHz are being used for MWA. 2,450 MHz is more commonly adopted by MWA which had been used for over 10 years in the treatment of liver tumors. Remarkable progresses had been made on the therapeutic outcome and MWA ablation thermal field [8,9] . There have been results of long-term survival rates of MWA for liver cancer in large cohort of patients. For small HCC (diameter ≤ 3 cm), MWA had achieved therapeutic effects equivalent to those obtained by “curative” hepatectomy, meanwhile showing significantly lower complications [6,10,11] . Liang et al. [12] reported their results of MWA in 288 patients with 477 tumors, among which 235 (82%) patients were not candidates for surgery. The 1-, 2-, 3-, 4- and 5-year cumulative survival rates were 93%, 82%, 72%, 63%, and 51%, respectively. For the treatment of large tumors, more effective antennae or simultaneous application of multiple antennae should be used to ensure complete coverage of the entire tumor with a safety margin. However, it would be difficult to achieve a complete ablation in one treating session. Meanwhile, an increased number of needle insertions to treat large tumors would cause significantly higher complication rates [13] . Compared with 2,450 MHz microwaves, 915 MHz microwaves have longer wavelength and deeper penetration depth owing to its lower frequency. 915 MHz microwaves are also characterized by the low-loss output, which means that it may generate a larger coagulation volume [14] . The feasibility of 915 MHz microwaves has been proved by experimental study and phantom study [6,7,15,16] . As shown by Simon et al. [17] , a mean maximal ablation diameter of 5.5 cm (range 5.0–6.5 cm) was obtained by intraoperative application of three antennae spaced 1.5–2.5 cm apart. As demonstrated by our team in early studies, compared with the 2,450 MHz microwaves, coagulation zones with 915 MHz antenna had larger long-axis and short-axis diameters [15] . However, the increase in short-axis diameter was limited for single antenna application and the coagulation shape was not suitable for tumor ablation. The purpose of this study is to investigate the MWA setting which can obtain a desirable coagulation geometry by simultaneous application of double 915 MHz antennae in ex vivo bovine livers. Hopefully it will provide a technical basis for treating larger liver tumor at one ablation session. 2 Materials and methods 2.1 Microwave system The microwave unit (KY-2200, Kangyou Medical, China) was used in this study. This unit consists of a microwave generator with frequencies of 915 MHz, a power output of 5–120 W, a flexible low-loss coaxial cable, a water-pumping machine, and a needle antenna. The generator is equipped with two output sources, allowing the simultaneous application of two microwave antennae. The cooled-shaft antenna has a diameter of 1.9 mm and a 20 cm shaft. The shaft has a coating with Teflon which is used to prevent tissue adhesion. A narrow radiating segment of 1.5 mm is embedded on the shaft, the active tip is 20-mm-long ( Fig. 1 ). The antenna has two channels inside the shaft lumen that enabled the delivery of distilled water to the tip of the shaft and the return of the warmed water to a 500-ml bottle. A steady-flow pump was used to push the chilled distilled water circulating within the channels of the antenna shaft at 20 ml/min, so that the shaft maintained a relatively low temperature during MW ablation. 2.2 Ex vivo study Eighteen fresh bovine livers were purchased from local markets. The livers were stored in an incubator at 37 °C for 30 min before use. Under direct visualization, microwave antennae were simultaneously inserted into the liver tissue with an implantation depth of 9–12 cm, to ensure the entire coagulation zone would be within the liver tissue. Continuous-wave MWAs were performed by using four power outputs at 50, 60, 70 and 80 W for 10 min. The distances between the two antennae were 2.0, 2.5 and 3.0 cm, respectively. A total of 12 experimental groups were employed in this study. For each power setting, MWA was repeated seven times and a total of 84 ablations were performed. After each ablation procedure, each ablated specimen was dissected from the liver and sectioned along the two parallel needles tracks. All procedures were performed by the two investigators (W.Y.S and Y.W), who have 10 and 6 years of experience with MWA, respectively. 2.3 Evaluation of coagulation shape and diameters For this study, the coagulation shape was assessed macroscopically. Calipers were used to measure the extent of gross coagulation area in the inter-antenna distances, the long-axis (along the needle axes) and short-axis (perpendicular to needle) diameters. Each ablated area consisted of three visually distinctive zones, which were the center zone (charring zone), white zone (coagulation zone), and red zone (congestion zone), respectively. The diameters were measured from the margins of the white zone, not from the surrounding margins of the red zone [11] . The results of all diameter measurements were made in consensus of the two observers. 2.4 Statistical analysis Results were expressed as mean ± standard deviation (SD). In this study, differences in the long-axis diameter and short-axis diameter between groups were evaluated by analysis of variance. All statistical analyses were performed by using Stata software (version 7.0; Stata Corporation, College Station, TX). P -Values less than 0.05 were considered to indicate a statistically significant difference. 3 Results 3.1 Correlation of the inter-antennae distances and the coagulation shape The excellent uniformity of ablation shape was achieved when the two antennae were simultaneously applied with the same implantation depth and power output. The coagulation geometry was related to the inter-antenna distance in each power group. The ablation zones were most spherical at an inter-antenna distance of 2.0 cm; a slight recess of the coagulation zone was observed in ablations at an inter-antenna distance of 2.5 cm; The recess became more evident in ablations at an inter-antenna distance of 3.0 cm ( Fig. 2 ). At an inter-antenna distance of 2.0 cm a spherical coagulation zone could be obtained under the four power settings 50, 60, 70 and 80 W for 10 min. No difference in geometry was observed among the four power settings. An arrow-shaped charring around the shaft was observed in every group. 3.2 Coagulation zone With an inter-antennae distance of 2.0 cm, the long-axis and short-axis coagulation diameter were enlarged with the increasing power output. Comparing power output at 70 with 80 W, the long-axis and short-axis coagulation diameter for 80 W were increased, but not statistically different from that of 70 W ( Table 1 ). Accordingly, the optimal coagulation geometry and volume were yielded by the simultaneous application of two antennae at 70 W for 10 min with an inter-antenna distance of 2.0 cm. The largest coagulation zone produced at power output of 50, 60, 70, and 80 W for 10 min, were 6.3 cm × 5.2 cm, 7.4 cm × 5.4 cm, 7.7 cm × 5.6 cm, and 7.8 cm × 6.1 cm, respectively. 4 Discussion In recent years, the potential role of MWA has become increasingly apparent, microwave device and antenna had been greatly improved [11,13,18,19] . The design of microwave antenna is crucial to the therapeutic efficacy. Suitable antenna should specifically match the dielectric properties of the tissue, which can minimize power feedback to ensure localized power deposition around the active tip of the antenna, and increase the amount of energy deposited in the tissue [20] . In this study, a 915 MHz internally cooled-shaft antenna was used. It has two channels inside the shaft lumen with distilled water circulated by a peristaltic pump to continuously cool the shaft. The low antenna shaft temperature can deliver more energy into the tissue without causing skin burn. In addition, low antenna shaft temperature can reduce higher temperature in the center to decrease tissue charring and improve energy transfer, which makes possible higher power output and longer treatment duration. As a result, the ablation zone can be remarkably expanded. Given that most tumors treatable with thermal ablation are spherical, the shape of ablation should also approximate a sphere, in order to generate a sufficient ablative margin while minimizing the destruction of normal surrounding tissue. Sun et al. [15] reported that the ablation zones of a 915 MHz single antenna microwave ablation in vivo porcine livers was ellipsoid. With the increase of power output, the increase of short-axis diameter was limited. 60 and 80 W for 10 min were used during MWAs, the short-axis coagulation diameter were 3.83 ± 0.86 cm and 3.84 ± 0.86 cm, respectively. To obtain a larger effective short-axis diameter, our presumption was that the antennae should be placed at a distance less than 3.0 cm between the antennae. Consequently three inter-antennae distances were applied: 2.0, 2.5 and 3.0 cm, respectively. The experimental results revealed that the most spherical coagulation shape was observed in ablation at the inter-antenna distance of 2.0 cm. One of the advantages of microwave ablation is that the multiple microwave energy sources simultaneously applied would not interfere with each other, so it could produce a greater ablation effect within a short treatment time [7] . Liang et al. reported [9] that microwave ablation by simultaneously using two antennae increased the efficiency of thermal compensation between coagulation points and shortened the temperature rising time, so the coagulation effect was improved. Currently, thermal ablation therapy is focused on yielding large-volume coagulation necrosis in tissue, and controlling the ablation shape, with the purpose to obtain complete ablation at one treatment procedure. Our ex vivo results showed that the long-axis and short-axis coagulation diameter enlarged with the increasing power output. The increase of short-axis coagulation diameter is more important in the treatment of larger tumors. However, the difference in coagulation size was not significant between the 70 and 80 W groups, because the increased tissue charring around the shaft limited the expansion of the coagulation zone. Thus increase of power output would not indefinitely expand the ablation volume. So the optimal coagulation shape and volume was yielded by the simultaneous application of two antennae at 70 W for 10 min with the inter-antenna distance of 2.0 cm in our study. Because microwave has highly thermal efficiency, the tissue surrounding the antenna will be rapid ablated, the loss of water tissue can prevent microwave energy deposition. Therefore, the balance between power deposition and perfusion-mediated cooling can be achieved for several minutes. As shown by Hines-Peralta et al. [11] , 90% transverse diameter of coagulation zone was formed by application of power outputs ranging from 50 to 150 W for 8 min or less, prolonged application could be not result in significant enlargement the coagulation diameters. Meanwhile, to ensure complete ablation and relative ease of use, according to our experiences, 10 min is suitable for completing microwave ablation, thus our coagulation time was set at 10 min. There are some limitations in our study. This study used fresh bovine liver as the proxy for human liver tumors, with no effect of blood perfusion. In the MWA treatment for malignant tumor, there would be differences in homogeneity, density of tumor tissue, and various thermophysical properties in different tumor tissue. Therefore, coagulation result difference would occur between experimental and clinical study. In addition, the application of two antennae instead of one also rises probability of complications or at least complicates the application. In conclusion, microwave ablation by the simultaneous application of double 915 MHz antennae could generate a large ablation zone and spherical coagulation geometry in ex vivo bovine liver without clefts between the two antennae. This technique may be advantageous for treating larger liver tumor in one ablation session. References [1] S.N. Goldberg J.W. Charboneau G.D. Dodd 3rd Image-guided tumor ablation: proposal for standardization of terms and reporting criteria Radiology 228 2003 335 345 [2] T. Shibata Y. Maetani H. Isoda Radiofrequency ablation for small hepatocellular carcinoma: prospective comparison of internally cooled electrode and expandable electrode Radiology 238 2006 346 353 [3] C.J. Simon D.E. Dupuy W.W. Mayo-smith Microwave ablation: principles and applications Radiographics 25 Suppl. 1 2005 S69 S83 [4] A. Gangi H. Alizadeh L. Wong Osteoid osteoma: percutaneous laser ablation and follow-up in 114 patients Radiology 242 2007 293 301 [5] F. Wu Z.B. Wang W.Z. Chen Preliminary experience using high intensity focused ultrasound for the treatment of patients with advanced stage renal malignancy J Urol 170 2003 2237 2240 [6] A.S. Wright L.A. Sampson T.F. Warner Radiofrequency versus microwave ablation in a hepatic porcine model Radiology 236 2005 132 139 [7] A.S. Wright F.T. Lee Jr. D.M. Mahvi Hepatic microwave ablation with multiple antennae results in synergistically larger zones of coagulation necrosis Ann Surg Oncol 10 2003 275 283 [8] B.W. Dong P. Liang X.L. Yu Percutaneous sonographically guided microwave coagulation therapy for hepatocellular carcinoma: results in 234 patients AJR 180 2003 1547 1555 [9] P. Liang B.W. Dong X.L. Yu Computer-aided dynamic simulation of microwave-induced thermal distribution in coagulation of liver cancer IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 48 2001 821 829 [10] T. Shibata Y. Iimuro Y. Yamamoto Small hepatocellular carcinoma: comparison of radiofrequency ablation and percutaneous microwave coagulation therapy Radiology 223 2002 331 337 [11] A.U. Hines-Peralta N. Pirani P. Cleqq Microwave ablation: results with a 2.45-GHz applicator in ex vivo bovine and in vivo porcine liver Radiology 239 2006 94 102 [12] P. Liang B.W. Dong X.L. Yu Prognostic factors for survival in patients with hepatocellular carcinoma after percutaneous microwave ablation Radiology 235 2005 299 307 [13] M. Kuang M.D. Lu X.Y. Xie Liver cancer: increased microwave delivery to ablation zone with cooled-shaft antenna—experimental and clinical studies Radiology 242 2007 914 924 [14] S. Pisa M. Cavagnaro P. Bernardi A 915-MHz antenna for microwave thermal ablation treatment-physical design: computer modeling and experimental measurement IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 48 2001 599 601 [15] S. Yuanyuan W. Yang N. Xiaoxia Comparison of ablation zone between 915- and 2450-MHz cooled-shaft microwave antenna: results in in vivo porcine livers AJR 192 2009 511 514 [16] S.A. Shock K. Meredith T.F. Warner Microwave ablation with loop antenna: in vivo porcine liver model Radiology 231 2004 143 149 [17] C.J. Simon D.E. Dupuy D.A. Iannitti Intraoperative triple antenna hepatic microwave ablation AJR 187 2006 W333 W340 [18] I. Longo G.B. Gentili M. Cerretelli A coaxial antenna with miniaturized choke for minimally invasive interstitial heating IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 50 2003 82 88 [19] A.D. Strickland P.J. Clegg N.J. Cronin Experimental study of large-volume microwave ablation in the liver Br J Surg 89 2002 1003 1007 [20] J.M. Bertram D. Yang M.C. Converse A review of coaxial-based interstitial antennas for hepatic microwave ablation Crit Rev Biomed Eng 34 2006 187 213