Abstract:Purpose Teaching and unit evaluations surveys are used to assess the quality of teaching and the quality of the unit of study. An analysis of teaching and unit evaluation survey practices in Australian universities suggests significant changes. One key change discussed in the paper is the shift from voluntary to mandatory use of surveys with the results used to assess and reward academic staff performance. The change in the direction is largely driven by the introduction of performance‐based funding as part of quality assurance arrangements. The paper aims to outline the current trends and changes and the implications in the future such as increased scrutiny of teaching and intrusion to academic autonomy. Design/methodology/approach The paper is based on the analysis of current teaching and unit evaluation practices across the Australian university sector. The paper presents the case of an Australian university that has introduced performance‐based reward using various measures to assess and reward academic staff such as the outcome of student satisfaction surveys. The analysis of external quality audit findings related to teacher and unit evaluations is also presented. Findings The findings suggest a shift in trend from the use of voluntary to mandatory tools to assess and reward quality teaching. The case of an Australian university outlined in the paper and the approach taken by seven other universities is largely driven by performance‐based funding. One of the key concerns for many in higher education is the intrusion of academic autonomy with increased focus on outcomes and less emphasis on resources needed to produce excellence in learning and teaching and research. The increased reliance on student happiness as a measure of educational quality raises the questions on whether high student satisfaction would strengthen academic rigour and student attainment of learning outcomes and generic skills which are seen as key factors in graduate exit standards. Practical implications The renewal of quality assurance and performance‐based funding using student satisfaction as a measure of educational quality will result in increased use of student voice to assess learning and teaching outcomes. Such direction will increase the accountability on academics to improve student experience and the measures will be used to assess academic staff performance. Originality/value The paper outlines the trends and changes in the teacher and unit evaluations in Australian universities and its implications in the future. The paper also provides a case of an Australian university that has recently made teacher and unit evaluations compulsory with the results used in academic staff annual performance review and linking reward with performance outcomes.

Award-winning university teachers' concepts of teaching

Exploring the Perceived Integrations Between Assessment and Metacognition: A Qualitative Inquiry of Three Award-Winning Teacher Educators' Conceptions of Assessment in a Hong Kong University Context

Drivers of Teaching Effectiveness: Views from Accounting Educator Exemplars in Australia

What makes an excellent lecturer? Academics’ perspectives on the discourse of ‘teaching excellence’ in higher education

Student Perceptions of the ‘Best’ Feedback Practices: An Evaluation of Student-Led Teaching Award Nominations at a Higher Education Institution.

Questioning the Impact of Teaching Fellowships on Excellent Teachers

Excellence in teaching for promotion and tenure in animal and dairy sciences at doctoral/research universities: a faculty perspective

Determining the Effectiveness of a Teacher Preparation Course by Exploring the Transfer of Complex Teaching Models by Graduates

Winning an External Teaching Award in Higher Education: Teacher Identity and Recipient Characteristics

Chinese Award-Winning Tutors’ Perceptions and Practices of Classroom-Based Assessment

The Impact Of Training Of University Teachers on their Teaching Skills, their Approach to Teaching and the Approach to Learning of their Students

Conceptions and Beliefs About “Good Teaching”: An integration of contrasting research areas

University Teacher Education‐‐Where are we in Australia?

Seven Principles of Effective University Learning and Teaching:A Comparison Between Earlier and Later Researches

What feedback literate teachers do: an empirically-derived competency framework

The changing nature of teaching and unit evaluations in Australian universities

Teacher self-efficacy and inclusive education practices: Rethinking teachers’ engagement with inclusive practices

‘Observation has set in’: comparing students and peers as reviewers of teaching

Exploring teacher perceptions of different types of ‘feedback practices’ in higher education: implications for teacher feedback literacy

Benefits to teachers of the professional learning portfolio: a case study

On Teaching Methods: The Personal Experiences of Teachers of English