Measurements of Proton High-Order Cumulants in Snn=3 GeV Au + Au Collisions and Implications for the QCD Critical Point

M. S. Abdallah,B. E. Aboona,J. Adam,L. Adamczyk,J. R. Adams,J. K. Adkins,G. Agakishiev,I Aggarwal,M. M. Aggarwal,Z. Ahammed,I Alekseev,D. M. Anderson,A. Aparin,E. C. Aschenauer,M. U. Ashraf,F. G. Atetalla,A. Attri,G. S. Averichev,V Bairathi,W. Baker,J. G. Ball Cap,K. Barish,A. Behera,R. Bellwied,P. Bhagat,A. Bhasin,J. Bielcik,J. Bielcikova,I. G. Bordyuzhin,J. D. Brandenburg,A. Brandin,I Bunzarov,X. Z. Cai,H. Caines,M. Calderon de la Barca Sanchez,D. Cebra,I Chakaberia,P. Chaloupka,B. K. Chan,F-H Chang,Z. Chang,N. Chankova-Bunzarova,A. Chatterjee,S. Chattopadhyay,D. Chen,J. Chen,J. H. Chen,X. Chen,Z. Chen,J. Cheng,M. Chevalier,S. Choudhury,W. Christie,X. Chu,H. J. Crawford,M. Csanad,M. Daugherity,T. G. Dedovich,I. M. Deppner,A. A. Derevschikov,A. Dhamija,L. Di Carlo,L. Didenko,P. Dixit,X. Dong,J. L. Drachenberg,E. Duckworth,J. C. Dunlop,N. Elsey,J. Engelage,G. Eppley,S. Esumi,O. Evdokimov,A. Ewigleben,O. Eyser,R. Fatemi,F. M. Fawzi,S. Fazio,P. Federic,J. Fedorisin,C. J. Feng,Y. Feng,P. Filip,E. Finch,Y. Fisyak,A. Francisco,C. Fu,L. Fulek,C. A. Gagliardi,T. Galatyuk,F. Geurts,N. Ghimire,A. Gibson,K. Gopal,X. Gou,D. Grosnick,A. Gupta,W. Guryn,A. Hamad,A. Hamed,Y. Han,S. Harabasz,M. D. Harasty,J. W. Harris,H. Harrison,S. He,W. He,X. H. He,Y. He,S. Heppelmann,N. Herrmann,E. Hoffman,L. Holub,Y. Hu,H. Huang,H. Z. Huang,S. L. Huang,T. Huang,X. Huang,Y. Huang,T. J. Humanic,G. Igo,D. Isenhower,W. W. Jacobs,C. Jena,A. Jentsch,Y. Ji,J. Jia,K. Jiang,X. Ju,E. G. Judd,S. Kabana,M. L. Kabir,S. Kagamaster,D. Kalinkin,K. Kang,D. Kapukchyan,K. Kauder,H. W. Ke,D. Keane,A. Kechechyan,M. Kelsey,Y. Khyzhniak,C. Kim,B. Kimelman,D. Kincses,I Kisel,A. Kiselev,A. G. Knospe,H. S. Ko,L. Kochenda,L. K. Kosarzewski,L. Kramarik,P. Kravtsov,L. Kumar,S. Kumar,R. Kunnawalkam Elayavalli,J. H. Kwasizur,R. Lacey,S. Lan,J. M. Landgraf,J. Lauret,A. Lebedev,R. Lednicky,J. H. Lee,Y. H. Leung,N. Lewis,C. Li,W. Li,X. Li,Y. Li,X. Liang,Y. Liang,R. Licenik,T. Lin,Y. Lin,M. A. Lisa,F. Liu,H. Liu,P. Liu,T. Liu,X. Liu,Y. Liu,Z. Liu,T. Ljubicic,W. J. Llope,R. S. Longacre,E. Loyd,N. S. Lukow,X. F. Luo,L. Ma,R. Ma,Y. G. Ma,N. Magdy,D. Mallick,S. Margetis,C. Markert,H. S. Matis,J. A. Mazer,N. G. Minaev,S. Mioduszewski,B. Mohanty,M. M. Mondal,I Mooney,D. A. Morozov,A. Mukherjee,M. Nagy,J. D. Nam,Md Nasim,K. Nayak,D. Neff,J. M. Nelson,D. B. Nemes,M. Nie,G. Nigmatkulov,T. Niida,R. Nishitani,L. Nogach,T. Nonaka,A. S. Nunes,G. Odyniec,A. Ogawa,S. Oh,V. A. Okorokov,B. S. Page,R. Pak,J. Pan,A. Pandav,A. K. Pandey,Y. Panebratsev,P. Parfenov,B. Pawlik,D. Pawlowska,C. Perkins,L. Pinsky,J. Pluta,B. R. Pokhrel,G. Ponimatkin,J. Porter,M. Posik,V Prozorova,N. K. Pruthi,M. Przybycien,J. Putschke,H. Qiu,A. Quintero,C. Racz,S. K. Radhakrishnan,N. Raha,R. L. Ray,R. Reed,H. G. Ritter,M. Robotkova,O. Rogachevskiy,J. L. Romero,D. Roy,L. Ruan,J. Rusnak,A. K. Sahoo,N. R. Sahoo,H. Sako,S. Salur,J. Sandweiss,S. Sato,W. B. Schmidke,N. Schmitz,B. R. Schweid,F. Seck,J. Seger,M. Sergeeva,R. Seto,P. Seyboth,N. Shah,E. Shahaliev,P. Shanmuganathan,M. Shao,T. Shao,A. Sheikh,D. Y. Shen,S. S. Shi,Y. Shi,Q. Y. Shou,E. P. Sichtermann,R. Sikora,M. Simko,J. Singh,S. Singha,M. J. Skoby,N. Smirnov,Y. Sohngen,W. Solyst,Y. Song,P. Sorensen,H. M. Spinka,B. Srivastava,T. D. S. Stanislaus,M. Stefaniak,D. J. Stewart,M. Strikhanov,B. Stringfellow,A. A. P. Suaide,M. Sumbera,B. Summa,X. M. Sun,X. Sun,Y. Sun,B. Surrow,D. N. Svirida,Z. W. Sweger,P. Szymanski,A. H. Tang,Z. Tang,A. Taranenko,T. Tarnowsky,J. H. Thomas,A. R. Timmins,D. Tlusty,T. Todoroki,M. Tokarev,C. A. Tomkiel,S. Trentalange,R. E. Tribble,P. Tribedy,S. K. Tripathy,T. Truhlar,B. A. Trzeciak,O. D. Tsai,Z. Tu,T. Ullrich,D. G. Underwood,I Upsal,G. Van Buren,J. Vanek,A. N. Vasiliev,I Vassiliev,V. Verkest,F. Videbaek,S. Vokal,S. A. Voloshin,F. Wang,G. Wang,J. S. Wang,P. Wang,X. Wang,Y. Wang,Z. Wang,J. C. Webb,P. C. Weidenkaff,L. Wen,G. D. Westfall,H. Wieman,S. W. Wissink,R. Witt,J. Wu,Y. Wu,B. Xi,Z. G. Xiao,G. Xie,W. Xie,H. Xu,N. Xu,Q. H. Xu,Y. Xu,Z. Xu,G. Yan,C. Yang,Q. Yang,S. Yang,Y. Yang,Z. Ye,L. Yi,K. Yip,Y. Yu,H. Zbroszczyk,W. Zha,C. Zhang,D. Zhang,J. Zhang,S. Zhang,X. P. Zhang,Y. Zhang,Z. J. Zhang,Z. Zhang,J. Zhao,C. Zhou,Y. Zhou,X. Zhu,M. Zurek,M. Zyzak
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.128.202303
IF: 8.6
2022-01-01
Physical Review Letters
Abstract:We report cumulants of the proton multiplicity distribution from dedicated fixed-target Au + Au collisions at root s(NN) = 3.0 GeV, measured by the STAR experiment in the kinematic acceptance of rapidity (y) and transverse momentum (p(T)) within -0.5 < y < 0 and 0.4 < p(T) < 2.0 GeV/c. In the most central 0%-5% collisions, a proton cumulant ratio is measured to be C-4/C-2 = -0.85 +/- 0.09 (stat) +/- 0.82 (syst), which is 2 sigma below the Poisson baseline with respect to both the statistical and systematic uncertainties. The hadronic transport UrQMD model reproduces our C-4/C-2 in the measured acceptance. Compared to higher energy results and the transport model calculations, the suppression in C-4/C-2 is consistent with fluctuations driven by baryon number conservation and indicates an energy regime dominated by hadronic interactions. These data imply that the QCD critical region, if created in heavy-ion collisions, could only exist at energies higher than 3 GeV.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?