Structured Survey of Human Factor-Related Maritime Accident Research

Xin Shi,Hui Zhuang,Dong Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oceaneng.2021.109561

IF: 5

2021-01-01

Ocean Engineering

Abstract:By using a structured analytic technique, this paper reviews the development of research on maritime accidents involving human factors (HFs). First, a clear framework is generated for consolidating the main viewpoints on diverse topics; it is structured in terms of focus, perspective, and methodology. In particular, research focus is further classified into factor identification, interaction investigation, and regulative intervention. Second, most generic HF-related accident models employed in the maritime domain are specialized for specific maritime situations: the HF analysis and classification system (HFACS) is the most commonly used model in factor identification studies; the few intervention-related studies only propose intervention measures; and studies on maritime HF-related accidents are more qualitative and retrospective than quantitative and prospective. Third, the following research gaps are identified: i) inadequate fundamental exploration of nonlinear interaction and intervening mechanisms, ii) lack of application-based conceptualization of maritime-specific analytical frameworks, and iii) methodological limitations regarding data collection and quantitative analysis. Finally, suggestions for future research are proposed, including establishing an “interlink net” rather than only a linear chain to explore interactions among causal factors; objectively investigating the effect of an intervention; constructing maritime-specific integrated models concerning the accident cause, interlinkage, and intervention; applying specific methods in data collection in accordance with the “potential” and “heterogeneity” of HFs.