Abstract:World language teachers have historically relied on the notion of teaching methods to inform elements of design and procedure in their instructional practice. Teacher beliefs about teaching methods, however, have been shown to be significantly influenced by their context, including their institution and their learners. This phenomenon has led some scholars to identify a postmethod condition, where teachers prioritize making responsive, principled decisions about instruction based on their context. This qualitative study investigated the patterns and realities of the postmethod condition in practice through the lens of teacher beliefs about teaching methods, focusing on ten secondary-level world language teachers of French and Spanish in the USA. Data sources included a survey about teaching methods, in-depth interviews, and classroom observations. Data analysis included descriptive statistics, multiple phases of coding, and integrating analysis of the three sources. Findings indicated that teachers in this group largely identified as adhering to one main teaching approach, with eight of the ten self-identifying as using primarily comprehensible input and/or TPRS (Teaching Proficiency through Reading and Storytelling) methods. However, through investigating their beliefs about grammar and accuracy; the four skills of reading, writing, listening, and speaking; the importance of input and output; and instructional flow, we found that the teachers examined and reexamined their teaching methods regularly, largely due to the influences of their learners and their institution. The relationship between the teachers’ beliefs and practices was mediated by context-driven instructional decision-making, indicating the presence of a postmethod condition.

Exploring Language Teachers' Beliefs about the Medium of Instruction and Actual Practices Using Complex Dynamic System Theory

Teachers' beliefs and practices: a dynamic and complex relationship

Understanding University Teachers' Beliefs and Practice in Using English As a Medium of Instruction

Teacher beliefs about instructional approaches: Interrogating the notion of teaching methods

A study of secondary school English teachers’ beliefs in the context of curriculum reform in China

The complex dynamics of adaptive teaching: observing teacher-student interaction in the language classroom

Language Teachers at Work

Spanish Language Teachers’ Pedagogical Beliefs in Chinese Universities

Understanding Chinese Language Teachers’ Beliefs about Themselves and Their Students in an English Context

Teachers’ Beliefs and Practices of Task-Based Language Teaching in Chinese as a Second Language Classrooms

Native English teachers’ beliefs and practices in teaching oral communication: A multiple case study in China

From Perceived Discrepancies to Intentional Efforts: Understanding English Department Teachers' Agency in Classroom Instruction in a Changing Curricular Landscape

Challenges and Responses: A Complex Dynamic Systems Approach to Exploring Language Teacher Agency in a Blended Classroom

An Exploratory Study on Chinese EFL Teachers’ Beliefs about Reading and Teaching Reading

Teacher beliefs about teaching French as a foreign language in a Chinese university: a multilingual perspective

Beliefs and Practices of Chinese University Teachers in EFL Writing Instruction

Exclusive use of the second language in classroom interaction in English Medium Instruction science classrooms: the beliefs of students and their monolingual teachers

Understanding language teachers' practice with educational technology: A case from China

Relationships Between Epistemological Beliefs, Conceptions of Teaching and Learning and Instructional Practices of Teachers: A Chinese Perspective

Reconciling the Evolving Conceptualisations of Language Teacher Cognition from an Activity Theory Perspective

Studies on language teachers' beliefs and emotions: Current status and future directions