Abstract:The metro system plays a very important role in the urban multimodal transportation system, yet it is susceptible to accidents. A well-designed metro system needs to provide alternative routes to travellers both in the disruptive events and the normal operating conditions for providing rerouting opportunities and balancing crowded lines. This paper provides a new dimension of assessing metro network performance—travellers’ route redundancy (or route diversity), which is defined as the number of behaviourally effective routes between each origin-destination (O-D) pair in the network. The route redundancy of metro network is evaluated by statistical indicators of the distribution of the O-D-level number of effective routes. Compared with the existing connectivity and accessibility measures of topology network performance, route redundancy is also based on the topology network, but it takes the travellers’ route choice into consideration. Specifically, the effective routes between each O-D pair would provide disaggregated information from the travellers’ perspective. Case studies in four metropolises in the world, i.e., Shanghai, Beijing, London, and Tokyo, are conducted to examine the predisaster preparedness of the four metro networks explicitly from the perspective of route redundancy. The results indicate that the London metro network has the best route redundancy performance in terms of the statistical indicators of the distribution of the O-D level number of effective routes. Furthermore, the results of route redundancy are compared with typical measures of topology network performance in terms of measuring connectivity and accessibility of metro networks. Their differences are attributed to the fact that the route redundancy measure considers the travellers’ O-D-level route choice beyond the pure network topology and the shortest path considerations of the existing measures. The route redundancy proposed in this paper could assist in evaluating the predisaster preparedness of current or planning metro networks from O-D level to network level.

Enhancing Network Resilience by Adding Redundancy to Road Networks

Economic evaluation of redundancy design for transportation networks under disruptions: Framework and case study

Identifying Critical Links in Transportation Networks Based on Route Diversity Redundancy

Assessing Transportation Network Redundancy by Integrating Route Diversity and Spare Capacity

Modeling Transportation Network Redundancy

An Optimization Approach for Deriving Upper and Lower Bounds of Transportation Network Vulnerability under Simultaneous Disruptions of Multiple Links

Resilience-Based Risk Mitigation for Road Networks

Transportation network redundancy: Complementary measures and computational methods

Identification Methods of Critical Combination of Vulnerable Links in Transportation Networks

Identifying the critical road combination in urban roads network under multiple disruption scenarios

Proactive Resilience Building through Route Diversity: A Close Look at the Metro System from the Travelers’ Perspective

Dr aft Network-based Assessment of Resilience of Road Systems

Measuring route diversity in spatial and spatial-temporal public transport networks

Route Redundancy-Based Network Topology Measure of Metro Networks

Network Reconfiguration for Increasing Transportation System Resilience Under Extreme Events

Resilience-based post-disaster recovery strategies for road-bridge networks

Network Structure Optimization Method for Urban Drainage Systems Considering Pipeline Redundancies

A Distributionally Robust Optimization for Reliability-Based Lane Reservation and Route Design Under Uncertainty

Resilience assessment and enhancement of urban road networks subject to traffic accidents: a network-scale optimization strategy

Resilience-based performance modeling and decision optimization for transportation network

Development of Network-Based Measures and Computational Methods for Evaluating the Redundancy of Transportation Networks