Abstract:In new industrial product development, human-involvement conceptual design evaluation (CDE) is an information-intensive and multi-criteria group decision-making (MCGDM) process. To capture and formalize the uncertain information from decision-makers (DMs), several derivations of fuzzy number such as triangular intuitionistic fuzzy number (TIFN), Z-number, and interval number have been employed in CDE, which only cover limited information. The main contributions of this paper are as follows: firstly, a new kind of fuzzy number by taking advantage of TIFN, Z-number and interval number, i.e., interval intuitionistic fuzzy-Z-number (IIFZN), is presented to utilize DM's preference value (PV) for alternative, as well as his important rating (IR) and familiarity degree (FD) judgements for evaluation criterion. IIFZN is composed of not only the membership and non-membership of PV or IR, but also the affiliated confidence coefficient transformed from FD. Then, in terms of the IIFZN-based decision-making matrix, this study proposes new ideal solution definition rules and distance measurement metric in technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution (TOPSIS) to form a new TOPSIS-IIFZN method. The proposed method will enable DM easily find the alternative which is most preferable for important and familiar criteria and least preferred for less important and unfamiliar criteria as the best one. It is more rational than traditional PV-only CDE method, which will help company to save manufacturing resources. Besides theoretical research, one practical example and three more complex comparative experiments have been carried out to validate the performance of TOPSIS-IIFZN. By comparing with other MCGDM methods using different types of fuzzy numbers, it proves that TOPSIS-IIFZN can obtain more reasonable evaluation results. Meanwhile, besides PV, the RI and FD factors also play great influences in CDE.

Conceptual Design Evaluation Considering Confidence Based on Z-AHP-TOPSIS Method

An Integrated Decision-Making Approach for Designing and Selecting Product Concepts Based on QFD and Cumulative Prospect Theory

Z-preference-based multi-criteria decision-making for design concept evaluation highlighting customer confidence attitude

Product Design Alternative Selection:an Integrated Approach with HOQ and PROMETHEE

A fuzzy rough number-based AHP-TOPSIS for design concept evaluation under uncertain environments

An integrated AHP and VIKOR for design concept evaluation based on rough number

An Integrated Rough Number-Based Approach to Design Concept Evaluation under Subjective Environments

Triangular Fuzzy QFD–MCDM Combination Approach for Green Building Design Scheme Evaluation

A New Integrated Design Concept Evaluation Approach Based on Vague Sets

Two-additive Fuzzy Measure-Based Information Integration Approach to Product Design Alternative Evaluation

New customer-oriented design concept evaluation by using improved Z-number-based multi-criteria decision-making method

An integrated product conceptual scheme decision approach based on Shapley value method and fuzzy logic for economic-technical objectives trade-off under uncertainty

Conceptual Design Evaluation Using Interval Intuitionistic Fuzzy-Z-Number for Multiple Uncertain Information from Decision-Maker

Group decision-making method with Pythagorean fuzzy rough number for the evaluation of best design concept

Evaluation Schemes Method for Design Based on Information Axiom and Fuzzy Mathematics

An Evaluation Method for Schemes of Mechanical Product Conceptual Design with Incomplete Multi-Technique-Parameters

New Evaluation Methods for Conceptual Design Selection Using Computational Intelligence Techniques

Decision Model for Product Design Based on Fuzzy Synthetic Evaluation Method

An integrated design concept evaluation model based on interval valued picture fuzzy set and improved GRP method

Evaluating design concepts using fuzzy arithmetic operations

Collaborative evaluation method for product concept based on Choquet integral and evidence theory