Abstract:Existing auditing literature focuses exclusively on rational incentives of investors, managers, and auditors to demand and supply high audit quality, ignoring the potential effect of behavior bias such as sentiment on audit quality. Investors and managers with high sentiment might pay less attention to audited financial statements in their decisions, which lowers their demand for audit quality. Auditors might lower their supply of audit quality if they share the same sentiment or they expect weaker investor monitoring from high sentiment investors, which could reduce auditors’ perceived litigation, reputation, and regulatory risk. We take advantage of the unique Chinese data on audit inputs because the input-based measures are directly under auditors’ control and less confounded than output-based audit quality measures. We find that high sentiment is associated with lower likelihood of audit adjustments and fewer audit hours, consistent with auditors providing low audit effort when sentiment is high. We also find that high sentiment is associated with lower likelihood of modified audit opinions and higher absolute discretionary accruals, consistent with auditors providing low quality outputs when sentiment is high. Cross-sectional analyses show that the effect of sentiment on audit quality is more pronounced for small audit firms, low regulation risk periods, larger clients, and optimistic sentiment. Finally, we show that the effect of sentiment on the output-based audit quality measures is generalizable to the U.S. Our paper is the first to identify behavior biases as a determinant of the clients’ demand and auditors’ supply of audit quality.

Junk Stocks Vs Quality Stocks, A Perspective from Mood Seasonality

Mood seasonality: Evidence from the Chinese A-share market

Price Nonsynchronicity, Idiosyncratic Risk, and Expected Stock Returns in China

Sources of the Stock Price Fluctuations in Chinese Equity Market

Timing sentiment with style: Evidence from mutual funds

The Excess Returns of "Quality" Stocks: A Behavioral Anomaly

News sentiment and stock return: Evidence from managers’ news coverages

Analyzing Stock Market Trends Using Social Media User Moods and Social Influence

Sentiment, Limited Attention and Factor Returns

Reference Price Distributions and Stock Returns: an Analysis Based on the Disposition Effect

Quality acceleration and cross-sectional returns: Empirical evidence

Sentiment and Audit Quality

Firm-specific investor sentiment, stock price synchronicity, and crash risk

Does the time horizon of the return predictive effect of investor sentiment vary with stock characteristics? A Granger causality analysis in the frequency domain

A Two-Dimensional Sentiment Analysis of Online Public Opinion and Future Financial Performance of Publicly Listed Companies

Investor Sentiment and the Pricing of Characteristics-Based Factors

Analyst Reports and Stock Performance: Evidence from the Chinese Market

Music Sentiment and Stock Returns Around the World

Market Sentiment and the Cross-section of Expected Stock Returns

Can Investor Sentiment Explain the Abnormal Returns of Volatility-Managed Portfolio Strategy? Evidence from the Chinese Stock Market

A new salient factor and equity returns: empirical evidence from A-Shares