The Gap Between Law And Practice: An Empirical Study On China'S High Pretrial Detention Rate

Xifen Lin,Zihui Gu,Xi Lin
2017-01-01
Hong kong law journal
Abstract:Through participatory observation and in-depth interviews with 38 practitioners, this research provides an explanation for the high pretrial detention rate in China by examining the underlying mechanisms as to how prosecutors make their decisions in practice. Three legal conditions for pretrial detention that should be simultaneously satisfied, ie, evidence condition, penalty condition and necessity condition, are either distortedly enforced or hardly enforced in practice. The complexity of enforcement of the legal requirements makes the "fewer and more cautious detention[s]" policy hardly realised in China. The implementation of China's pretrial detention also suggests that fact-finding, though of the utmost importance in China's criminal justice system, might sometimes make a concession to crime control. Also, compared to fact-finding and crime control, protection of human rights and due process of law are usually under-evaluated.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?