Abstract:Background In observational studies, double robust or multiply robust (MR) approaches provide more protection from model misspecification than the inverse probability weighting and g-computation for estimating the average treatment effect (ATE). However, the approaches are based on parametric models, leading to biased estimates when all models are incorrectly specified. Nonparametric methods, such as machine learning or nonparametric double robust approaches, are robust to model misspecification, but the efficiency of nonparametric methods is low. Method In the study, we proposed an improved MR method combining parametric and nonparametric models based on the previous MR method (Han, JASA 109(507):1159-73, 2014) to improve the robustness to model misspecification and the efficiency. We performed comprehensive simulations to evaluate the performance of the proposed method. Results Our simulation study showed that the MR estimators with only outcome regression (OR) models, where one of the models was a nonparametric model, were the most recommended because of the robustness to model misspecification and the lowest root mean square error (RMSE) when including a correct parametric OR model. And the performance of the recommended estimators was comparative, even if all parametric models were misspecified. As an application, the proposed method was used to estimate the effect of social activity on depression levels in the China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Study dataset. Conclusions The proposed estimator with nonparametric and parametric models is more robust to model misspecification.

Weighted Least Relative Error Estimation For Multiplicative Regression Model

Least Absolute Relative Error Estimation

Least Product Relative Error Estimation

Model Averaging Estimation for Nonparametric Varying-Coefficient Models with Multiplicative Heteroscedasticity

Regression analysis of multiplicative hazards model with time-dependent coefficient for sparse longitudinal covariates

Weighted Lasso Estimates for Sparse Logistic Regression: Non-Asymptotic Properties with Measurement Errors

Optimal Weighting Distance-Based Similarity for Locally Weighted PLS Modeling

Estimation of nonstationary nonparametric regression model with multiplicative structure

Modelling additive extremile regression by iteratively penalized least asymmetric weighted squares and gradient descent boosting

On the relative and multiplicative model reductions

Weighted Profile Least Squares Estimation for a Panel Data Varying-Coefficient Partially Linear Model

On Estimating the Nonparametric Multiplicative Error Models

A compromise criterion for weighted least squares estimates

M robust bias-corrected weighted least squares iteration solution of mixed additive and multiplicative random error model

Relative error-based distributed estimation in growing dimensions

Estimation and hypothesis test for varying coefficient single-index multiplicative models

Robust explicit estimators using the power-weighted repeated medians

Statistical Inference of Seemingly Unrelated Partially Linear Additive Regression Models

An improved multiply robust estimator for the average treatment effect

Parameter Estimation of Jelinski-Moranda Model Based on Weighted Nonlinear Least Squares and Heteroscedasticity

A principal-weighted penalized regression model and its application in economic modeling