Abstract:Object-based image classification for land-cover mapping purposes using remote-sensing imagery has attracted significant attention in recent years. Numerous studies conducted over the past decade have investigated a broad array of sensors, feature selection, classifiers, and other factors of interest. However, these research results have not yet been synthesized to provide coherent guidance on the effect of different supervised object-based land-cover classification processes. In this study, we first construct a database with 28 fields using qualitative and quantitative information extracted from 254 experimental cases described in 173 scientific papers. Second, the results of the meta-analysis are reported, including general characteristics of the studies (e.g., the geographic range of relevant institutes, preferred journals) and the relationships between factors of interest (e.g., spatial resolution and study area or optimal segmentation scale, accuracy and number of targeted classes), especially with respect to the classification accuracy of different sensors, segmentation scale, training set size, supervised classifiers, and land-cover types. Third, useful data on supervised object-based image classification are determined from the meta-analysis. For example, we find that supervised object-based classification is currently experiencing rapid advances, while development of the fuzzy technique is limited in the object-based framework. Furthermore, spatial resolution correlates with the optimal segmentation scale and study area, and Random Forest (RF) shows the best performance in object-based classification. The area-based accuracy assessment method can obtain stable classification performance, and indicates a strong correlation between accuracy and training set size, while the accuracy of the point-based method is likely to be unstable due to mixed objects. In addition, the overall accuracy benefits from higher spatial resolution images (e.g., unmanned aerial vehicle) or agricultural sites where it also correlates with the number of targeted classes. More than 95.6% of studies involve an area less than 300ha, and the spatial resolution of images is predominantly between 0 and 2m. Furthermore, we identify some methods that may advance supervised object-based image classification. For example, deep learning and type-2 fuzzy techniques may further improve classification accuracy. Lastly, scientists are strongly encouraged to report results of uncertainty studies to further explore the effects of varied factors on supervised object-based image classification.

Consistency Analysis Of Multi-Source Remotely Sensed Images For Land Cover Classification

Multiclass SVM based land cover classification with multisource data

Consistency Evaluation and Integration Application of Land Cover Classification Results from Multi-source Remotely Sensed Images

Assessment of Ensemble Learning for Object-Based Land Cover Mapping Using Multi-Temporal Sentinel-1/2 Images

Consistency Measure of Multiple Classifiers for Land Cover Classification by Remote Sensing Image.

Multisource Earth Observation Data for Land-Cover Classification Using Random Forest

Continuous Multi-Angle Remote Sensing and Its Application in Urban Land Cover Classification

Integrating Multi-Temporal Spectral and Structural Information from ALOS/AVNIR-2 Images to Map Heterogeneous Land Use/Cover: A Hybrid Approach

Comparison of multiple Chinese earth observation data for urban land use classification with different classification methods

Inconsistency among Landsat Sensors in Land Surface Mapping: A Comprehensive Investigation Based on Simulation

A review of supervised object-based land-cover image classification

A new strategy based on multi-source remote sensing data for improving the accuracy of land use/cover change classification

Improving Urban Land Cover Classification with Combined Use of Sentinel-2 and Sentinel-1 Imagery

High Resolution Remotely Sensed Imagery Classification For Urban Environment Monitoring Based On Support Vector Machine

Comparison of Simulated Multispectral Reflectance among Four Sensors in Land Cover Classification

Comparing Spectral Angle Mapper And Object Based Approach For Land Use Classification From Multispectral Imagery

Automatic Classification of Remote Sensing Images Using Multiple Classifier Systems

Mapping Urban Land Cover Using Multiple Criteria Spectral Mixture Analysis: A Case Study in Chengdu, China.

A Comparison of Multiple Classifier Combinations Using Different Voting-Weights for Remote Sensing Image Classification

Consistency Analysis and Accuracy Evaluation of Multi-Source Land Cover Data Products in the Eastern European Plain

METHODS AND ACCURACY ASSESSMENT FOR LAND USE AND COVER CLASSIFICATION BASED ON MEDIUM RESOLUTION REMOTELY SENSED DATA