Abstract:Airport projects can have a significant impact on sustainable development. In Germany, as in many other developed countries, airport development is confronting a dilemma because, on the one hand, airports are important infrastructural components and, on the other hand, airport development faces strong resistance from local populations and interest groups. Thus, uncertainties and long time periods, up to 20 years from the beginning of planning to breaking ground, are quite normal. To ease airport development in Germany, administrative procedures and public participation were enhanced. Nevertheless, even with improved public participation, siting decisions in the case of Berlin Brandenburg Airport (BER) were lengthy as usual and remain controversial today due to the selection of Schönefeld as the site. Against this background, it seems that public participation in the case of the BER site selection did not particularly deliver the hoped-for results, but why? To answer this question, Creighton’s principles of effective public participation are employed as benchmarks. Moreover, the benchmarking indicates that public participation was not effectively applied. Thus, the possible benefits of public participation could not or could only be partly reaped. Furthermore, from a broader politico-economic perspective, the analysis exposes that public participation was just “a small cog in the machine” of the BER site selection process. It seems that other factors had a more substantial influence on the siting decision than public participation and led decision makers, in addition to regular challenges, into a predicament that might have made Schönefeld the only possible siting solution. In this context, different counterfactual scenarios are discussed to show under which circumstances other outcomes might have occurred regarding the BER site selection.

A New Guideline for 'ex Ante' Evaluation of Large Infrastructure Projects in the Netherlands

De Opmerkelijke Terugkeer Van De Kosten-Batenanalyse in Het Centrum Van De Bestuurspraktijk

Exposing weaknesses in interactive planning: the remarkable return of comprehensive policy analysis in The Netherlands

In Search of the Ideal Institutional Structure for Decision-making on Transport Infrastructure: A Conjoint Analysis of Expert Opinions on Hybrid Forms of German, Danish and Dutch Decision-making

Exchanging experiences in transport infrastructure policies between Denmark and the Netherlands

Decision-Making in the Transport Sector: A Sustainable Evaluation Method for Road Infrastructure

Cost-effective Use of Evaluation Models: an Empirical Cross-National Investigation

Towards a better comparison of ex-post and ex-ante BCA's by decomposing potential causes of difference

The Introduction of Public-Private Partnerships in the Netherlands As a Case of Institutional Bricolage: the Evolution of an Anglo-Saxon Transplant in a Rhineland Context

Characteristics of Cost Overruns for Dutch Transport Infrastructure Projects and the Importance of the Decision to Build and Project Phases

How To Build Major Transport Infrastructure Projects Within Budget, In Time And With The Expected Output; A Literature Review

Cost-Benefit Analysis for Flood Risk Management and Water Governance in the Netherlands: An Overview of One Century

Global Post-Evaluation for Highway Construction Projects

Economic Analysis and Investment Priorities in Sweden’s Transport Sector

Infrastructure Coopetition and the Creation of Value: an Anglo-Dutch Comparison of Regulatory Regimes for the Provision of Rail and Telephony Services

The Impact of Institutional Structures on Transport Infrastructure Performance. A Cross-National Comparison on Various Indicators

Cost-benefit analysis of transport projects: Theoretical framework and practical rules

Integrated urban renewal in The Netherlands: a critical appraisal

Public sector cost management practices in The Netherlands

Preparation and implementation of seven ecological compensation plans for Dutch highways

Public Participation and Airport Development: the Case of the Site Selection for Berlin Brandenburg Airport (BER) in Germany