Comparison Of Ahp And Disaster Loss Rate Method In The Application Of Disaster Risk Management - Of Rrought In Anhui Province

Yuting Wen,Ning Li,Wei Xie,Xueqin Liu,Jidong Wu,Peng Zhang
2011-01-01
Abstract:Regional risk map is an important basis for natural disaster risk management, which is made by Analytic Hierarchy Process and Disaster Loss Rate usually. However, the results of various methods are of differences, and this has brought some troubles to decision-makers. In this paper, weather experts, agricultural experts, disaster prevention and mitigation experts and non-experts are invited to construct comparison matrix and use AHP to assess the wheat drought disaster risks in Anhui Province, and then compare the results of AHP and Disaster Loss Rate and the actual distribution of drought by Euclidean distance method. The comparisons show that the four regional drought risk maps obtained by AHP deviate from the actual situation very much and exist diversities because comparison matrix is subjective, but the result of Disaster Loss Rate is closer to reality without the influence of many human factors.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?