Evaluation of water use efficiency in Yellow River Irrigation Area based on flow-tracing and layered-weight method
Feng Feng,Ni Guangheng,Meng Yuqing
DOI: https://doi.org/10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2017.10.019
2017-01-01
Abstract:There is an obvious gap between China's current irrigation water use efficiency and the world's advanced level for that of China is only 0.50, whereas that of world's advanced level reaches 0.7-0.8. Therefore, saving water resources, improving agricultural irrigation water efficiency, and ensuring the irrigation efficiency will be a long-term strategic task in the future of China. The purpose of this paper was to make a comprehensive evaluation for water use efficiency of Yellow River irrigation area based on flow-tracing and multiple weights method. In order to make a good comprehensive evaluation for water using efficiency, an open index-evaluation system including 19 deterministic index and 3 sub-systems based on irrigation flow-tracing method. Then, the improved fuzzy evaluation model was constructed based on multiple layer-weight determination method by making use of multi-objective and multi-level system. In the first layer (input layer), the index weight was confirmed by calculating entropy-weight-vector, and in the second layer (criterion layer), the sub-system weight was confirmed by the entropy- weight-vector method, equal-weight method and experience weight method, respectively for multi-layer weights. Finally, obtaining data and comparing different weights from the evaluation results was carried out by the fuzzy evaluation model. The paper took Sanyizhai Irrigation Area in lower reaches of the Yellow River as a case study. Sanyizhai Irrigation Area is located in the eastern plain of Henan Province (34°52?N, 144°44?E), north of the Yellow River. Sanyizhai Irrigation Area was founded in 1958, and it involves 18 counties scattered in Kaifeng, Shangqiu and Heze in Henan Province, and Shandong Provinces as well. Up to now, the water-diverting capacity of Sanyizhai Irrigation Area is about 150 m3/s, and irrigation area covers 9 counties(districts) mainly in the eastern part of Henan province, that is: Kaifeng, Lankao and Qi counties of Kaifeng City, Minquan County, Ningling County, Suiyang District, Liangyuan District, Sui County and Yucheng County of Shangqiu City respectively. The total land area of Sanyizhai Irrigation Area reaches 4344.2 km2 and the total cultivated area is 2701.42 km2. The paper took 10 years data from 2005 to 2014 of Sanyizhai Irrigation Area as a case study to make a comprehensive evaluation for water use efficiency. The 3 kinds of weight was used for the calculation. The results showed that: the first entropy-weight-vector weight was 0.307, 0.348, 0.345, the second equal-weight was 0.333, 0.333, 0.334, and the third subjective weight was 0.400, 0.200, 0.400. The evaluation result presented a general identical trend and showed that weight-influence was very limited for the evaluation result. According to the evaluation result, the irrigation water effect in 2013 was optimal among 10 years with average value 0.993 by comprehensive evaluation. Meanwhile, this evaluation results were in conformity with the actual situation of Sanyizhai Irrigation Area. In 2013 the rainfall and groundwater is relatively small, whereas the practical diverted irrigation intake and irrigation area has kept high level, which has ensured irrigation effect of and crop-harvest. According to the evaluation value of second layer, the dynamic variation process about engineering factors and management factors could be seen clearly, which showed that it kept a low-level development before 2007 and entered into a higher level development after 2009, so it could help us find the existing problems in irrigation process and provides data basis and technical support for the scientific planning and sustainable development of Yellow River Irrigation Area.