Abstract:Researchers have shown that the physiological-based personal comfort models (PCM) are capable of addressing individual differences as well as transient thermal comfort. Given that physiological-based comfort modeling studies are often very resource-intensive, a well-developed Design of Experiment (DOE) framework could help by optimizing the experimental sequence and use of resources. This study critically reviewed 74 physiological-based PCMs studies and dissected each study based on a DOE framework, dividing the experiments into the experimental procedures, sequences and variables settings. The results indicate that skin temperature, subjects' thermal sensation and air temperature are the leading input variables for PCM. Additionally, the most dominant experiment settings include a 1-min physiological data sampling interval, 10 min interval for reporting thermal vote, a less than 3 h experimental duration, and a fixed clothing level. We found that the subjects' number is independent of the experimental duration (correlation coefficient of 0.0201). Different activity levels and submerging subjects' hands into hot water are also used as thermal stimuli, in addition to the change in air temperature. By applying diverse algorithms, the average predicting accuracy of PCM from selected studies could achieve 85%, and Support Vector Machines (SVM) shows a superior predicting performance. The prominent limitations of the existing studies include insufficient subject numbers, technical restrictions of sensing devices, cumbersome data collection interfaces, improper machine learning algorithms and lack of diversity consideration. Finally, the review suggested that more related in this field should be compiled for cross-validation, helping to trade off the most appropriate experiment designs corresponding to the study objectives.

On-Line Adaptive Personalized Dynamic Thermal Comfort (Pdtc) Model Using Recursive Least Square Estimation

A Data-Driven Method to Describe the Personalized Dynamic Thermal Comfort in Ordinary Office Environment: from Model to Application

Comparison among Different Modeling Approaches for Personalized Thermal Comfort Prediction when Using Personal Comfort Systems

A Hybrid Physics-Based/data-driven Model for Personalized Dynamic Thermal Comfort in Ordinary Office Environment

A Multiple Model Approach for Predictive Control of Indoor Thermal Environment with High Resolution

A Model-Driven Learning Approach for Predicting the Personalized Dynamic Thermal Comfort in Ordinary Office Environment

Rapid Establishment Method of a Personalized Thermal Comfort Prediction Model

Comparison among different modeling approaches for personal comfort prediction when using personal comfort systems

Development of an Automatic Personal Comfort System (APCS) Based on Real-Time Thermal Sensation Prediction

Personalised Thermal Comfort Model for Automatic Control of a Newly Developed Personalised Environmental Control System (PECS)

Thermal preference prediction based on occupants’ adaptive behavior in indoor environments- A study of an air-conditioned multi-occupancy office in China

Research on Prediction and Regulation of Thermal Dissatisfaction Rate Based on Personalized Differences

Double Deep Q-learning Based on Personalized Thermal Comfort Model for HVAC Optimization

Personal thermal comfort models with wearable sensors

Personal thermal comfort models: a deep learning approach for predicting older people’s thermal preference

Study On An Adaptive Thermal Comfort Model With K-Nearest-Neighbors (Knn) Algorithm

Coupling CFD and human body thermoregulation model for the assessment of personalized ventilation

Personalized Thermal Comfort Modeling Based on Support Vector Classification

Impact of thermal control by real-time PMV using estimated occupants personal factors of metabolic rate and clothing insulation

Hybrid personalized thermal comfort model based on wrist skin temperature

Personal thermal comfort models based on physiological measurements – A design of experiments based review