RELATIVE EFFECTS OF PROTEIN AND LIPOTROPIC SUBSTANCES IN THE TREATMENT OF NUTRITIONAL CIRRHOSIS IN RATS
A. Patek,I. Plough,M. Bevans
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1749-6632.1954.tb36453.x
IF: 6.499
1954-05-01
Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences
Abstract:It is established that rats fed diets low in protein and deficient in lipotropic substances develop fatty changes and cirrhosis of the liver. It has also been shown that the addition of choline and methionine to these diets prevents the development of the lesions. Fewer studies have dealt with the treatment of nutritional cirrhosis once it is fully developed. The fmt reports on treatment of dietary cirrhosis in the rat were those of Lowry, Daft, Sebrell, Ashburn, and Lillie.', After producing cirrhosis in weanling rats with a diet containing 4 per cent casein, liver biopsies were performed, after which the animals were placed in two therapeutic groups,' one receiving the basal diet plus 40 mgm. of choline daily, the other receiving a high casein diet containing either 30 or 50 per cent casein. In a short term study, animals were sacrificed at intervals up to 42 days and, in a longer term study, a t intervals up to one year. Comparison was made with the initial biopsies. In both groups, the addition of choline to the basal diet and the change to a higher casein diet brought about disappearance of fat, regeneration of liver cells, but no apparent decrease in the amount of connective tissue. Sellers, Lucas, and Best3 tested various dietary regimens on young adult rats with cirrhosis of the liver induced by carbon tetrachloride poisoning. After a moderate degree of cirrhosis was produced, a representative sample was sacriiiced for control studies, the remainder being placed on the test diets for 12 to 13 weeks. In these experiments, the addition of choline, of methionine, or an increased proportion of casein brought about disappearance of fat, regeneration of liver cells, and loss of connective tissue as well. These agents seemed to be equally effective. It was concluded, therefore, that the reparative effects were attributable largely to lipotropic substances. In a more recent report by Gyiirgy and Goldblatt? employing a large series of rats, doubt was thrown on the effectiveness of lipotropic substances, more particularly in advanced stages of the disease. Because of the high mortality involved, biopsy technique was abandoned, and their observations were based largely upon sampling after 75 to 150 days of treatment. In those animals with moderate degrees of cirrhosis, lipotropic substances seemed to exert a curative effect, whereas in more advanced cirrhosis, the addition of these substances to the basal diet was much less effective. Best results were obtained by a combination of casein and liver extract. In the experiments to be described, nutritional cirrhosis was produced in the rat by a diet patterned after that of Daft, Sebrell, and Lillie.5 An attempt was made to Washingtm, D. C.; Goldwater Memorial Hospital, New York